How many times do you get introduced to someone all your friends like, but all you can think is

I don't really have much of a friend circle but it has happened to me too
like for example I've met few elderly people whom everyone admire while for me I respect them by default but I sometimes I feel something is off

I'm like that with almost everyone

It’s likely because they’re alien agents and you’re the only person for 100 miles with the innate ability to detect them, without knowing what it means. seems rather plausible

Yep- it's a talent from my mum's side.

Usually it the opposite. I’m that guy people think is a little off. 😆

Not often, but I'm always right.