Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Should radical Republicans in the US acknowledge they're not Conservatives anymore?

As someone with what I think are actually pretty conservative views about some " dying Western Civilization values" like honesty in dealing with others and respect for other human beings in light of the common benefits we can all get from cooperating and compromising, I think this kind of intellectual honesty might be productive.

This Federalist piece made a lot of sense to me, even though I'm not a radical reconstructionist or a counterrevolutionary, etc.

And I feel like, with this kind of honest reflection about stuff like small vs big government, and weighing the ends and the means (or at least acknowledging the risk that some means might pose), there's room to find common interests and compromises.


https://thefederalist.com/2022/10/20/we-need-to-stop-calling-ourselves-conservatives/
Classical conservatives haven’t been in charge of the GOP since Reagan was elected. That marked the party’s transition to white nationalism and fundamentalist Christianity. It also marked the beginning of fear and hatred of government while not hesitating to use government to oppress BIPOC, immigrants, LGBT, women, and others. Trump was just the latest expression of this.
Kwek00 · 41-45, M
Wanting to preserve liberty and civil society, by advocating for a dramatic expansion of the criminal code and wielding governement power as a blunt instrument.

... sounds like a nice guy, just keep him on your side of the ocean. Thx.
He might argue that what he wants to conserve is already gone, and therefore you can't conserve it no more. But he does believe it's not gone enough, considering that he'll be able to have a base that will allow this revolutionary program to happen.
Kwek00 · 41-45, M
@MistyCee That's because Fox News Bobbleheads play a diffrent roll. I don't think they would survive on FOX if they went all revolutanary. But what some of their pundits are pushing... if you follow it to their logical conclussion, it will end up with the same sentiments that the author of the opinion piece is pushing.

And Trump isn't an ideologue imo, he's an opportunist. He uses the tools he can find in society to amass power and gain wealth. AT the end of the day, he doesn't really care how he does it and who he uses, as long as it works.
@Kwek00 Fox isn't really as interested, imo, in fomenting the end of Western Civilization, or changing it, as it is in profiting from its audience, which leans that way.

In that sense, I think Trump and Murdoch are pretty much on the same page, although theyre both looking out for their own interests

That's where I'm actually a little pleased with this Federalist piece, though, because I can see where there's an actual ideology of sorts and an analysis that would never sell on Fox. O'Reilly, honestly, I felt like tried to go there, but he got killed off, largely because he was pushing an ideology and a level of intellectual analysis that was dangerous to Fox, all the sexual harassment and other stuff to the side

(although, I'd submit that it's actually part and parcel of the whole issue on a bigger scale. Fox plays with maleovolence and abuse of other human beings when it suits it's profit margin, but it's not really committed to might makes right).

At the end of the day, though, I'm pretty happy to see an articulate and relatively thoughtful analysis coming through somewhere, even if it's from the Federalist.

Increasingly, between Trump and the Fox News commercialization of the Republican party (and the left/establishment/liberal reaction to it, I've seen very little chance of addressing issues in a way that can result in compromises.

Take for example, government. This guy at least acknowledges government has a role, instead of just whining about how it can stifle individual freedom.

I really think, like, if more people read and understood this stuff, as opposed to just watching Fox and buying they're the bad guys, we'd be better off.
Kwek00 · 41-45, M
@MistyCee I'm not sure who is the boss or final editor at Fox, but I still think that they try not to cross the line of preaching revolution. Their guest might, but the pundits themselves won't do it imo. It's more about keeping people pissed off and glued to the screen.

I'm not sure about Murdoch and Trump, these people seem to just use eachother. One wants attention the other wants the money. As long as it doesn't reflect badly on Murdoch it seems to be all nice from where I'm standing. But Murdoch also seems to turn away when it becomes to extreme.

If you want to read right wing ideas, they are pretty far spread Misty. I can't acess it right now, but I believe the Patriot Front website has an entire piece on why they excist and what they want to do. And if you want a European variant like: "Against Democracy and Equality" from Tomislav Sunic. You can read stuff from Alain de Benoit. You even have a publisher, a popular example is "Arktos". And you can read political scientists that look at these organisations. Cas Mudde is intresting one if you want to go broad. And "The Flag and the Cross" by Gorski ad Perry is really fascinating if you want the US specifically. You also have a book called "How the south won the civil war" by Heather C. Richardson, she also has some nice stuff on youtube. I mean, you can really let yourself go if you are intrested behind what these people believe and sell to their wannabe electorate.

I thought during the Trum era, it was pretty clear that the governement has an important roll too. These people were talking about teaching the children a "pro-American curriculum that celebrates the truth" and are going to crack down on women that were going to have an abortion. I also can't believe that kicking transsexuals out of the army would be the end of that discussion. Like, these authoritarians aren't really for "small governement".

What if more people read this kind of stuff, and just agree? I mean, what these people are selling has an attraction. And of course, it's never going to be "that bad", these people wouldn't really go that far. But these true believers, that think that the ends justify the means, and talk about turning a governement into a blunt instrument to do what they want. Well... I rather don't have it around me.
BackyardShaman · 61-69, M
I think they should stop masquerading as conservatives yes.
Crazywaterspring · 61-69, M
@BackyardShaman Honest? Just admit their embracing of fascism.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
@MalteseFalconPunch Yeah, I appreciate your response, but I'm not sure how, if your a radical, "nothing good comes from that?"


Are you saying you want more folks to come out of the closet?


PS: I'm having fun. No disrespect intended.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Northwest · M
They never were. The GOP always provided them with a fig leaf. MAGA allowed one of their own, Donald J. Trump, to become President. They no longer have to hide. Their numbers, as slim as they may be, will tip the balance, and allow them to blackmail the GOP in all but the bluest of races.
@Northwest Yeah, I was trying not to bring this back to Trump, in particular, though.
[media=https://youtu.be/oyLwqzQ_3jA]What They Believe
@MistyCee here is they very first ones they made..
[media=https://youtu.be/snOebCXlMbU]MAGA Church
@markansas Yeah I get that, or at least got it in 2020, and I appreciate that they think they're the "true Republicans," but politics aside, I'm baffled and intrigued by who they're videos are intended for.

At least half of their early stuff seemed to be aimed at tweaking Trump personally, despite the fact that it was obviously also aimed at a broader audience as well.

My guess is, after the midterms, or at least by 2024, this enterprise will be dead.
@MistyCee if trump fails and the ones around him do also.. then they did there job and did it well. it was made for all to watch both sides to watch. and when trump and his are done then i think they will be gone..
Same questions to the radicals in the Democratic Party, or have they overcome that hurdle and openly avowed their radicalism and whatever it brings along?
@soar2newhighs the Dems are as far right as the Republicans, it's true, America has no left at all.
@Roundandroundwego You must loathe Democrats to take that position!
@soar2newhighs there's no political difference between the corporate right and the corporate left. Loathing gets you nowhere. America is dedicated to owning the end of the ecosystem.
Zonuss · 41-45, M
They may not be Conservative Republicans, but they are Republicans. And they are comfortable with the identity that they always have had.
Colonialism is their values.

 
Post Comment