Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I Was Shocked

I overheard my dad talking to my mom. He told her that if my sister (who's Jewish) married a Christian, he would basically shun her. I think he means it. He's very serious about us marrying within the Jewish religion. He's worried if we'll have kids, we won't raise them Jewish. I knew he felt strongly about marrying Jews but I didn't think he would go so far as to say we'll be dead to him if we do. I see things from his perspective in which a lot of religious people feel the same way. But he should also be thinking about [i]our[/i] happiness. This guy my sister is seeing makes her happy. When my mom wanted to talk to him more about it, he had a tantrum and went into his room saying he doesn't want to talk about it anymore and slammed the door like a child. I'm not saying they'll last in the long run but they both deeply care about each other. He goes and says that my mom is "encouraging" this. All she's encouraging is my sister's happiness. The only thing that would disappoint my mom is if we converted out of the religion which we told her will never happen. What's your opinion on this?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
This is a very difficult issue. There is a lot written about the loss of religion, all "standard religion" because of assimilation. The "shunning" may even occur within the religion when one marries another within the religion, but considered less religion. It is also said that mellenials are more spiritual but do not join congregations, regardless of which religion. This will also threaten organized religion.

Everyone must sit and discuss his issue, BEFORE things get too complicated.
JewStar4Life · 31-35, F
That's the problem. My dad doesn't discuss anything. What he says goes. He's stubborn that way. At least my mom isn't.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
Give him time. Have you seen "fiddler on the Roof" ? If
JewStar4Life · 31-35, F
@samueltyler2: No. LOL. But it's been on my watchlist for a while. It's just a long movie that I need a lot of free time to see it. But yeah, I feel like my dad means it when he says he'll shun us. I just hope that if that happens, my mom will stand her ground against him. I know she wants grandkids and would want to be in their lives as well as ours.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
You need to find an intermediary who might be able to work to have yur father accept the fact that he will still love his children and will hurt himself by "shunning."
JewStar4Life · 31-35, F
@samueltyler2: Yeah. I would think if he truly loved us, he would want us to be happy in any way we want to be. One time, I asked my mom that if my dad wasn't Jewish if she would have still married him and she said yes. She loves him that much. I asked my dad the same question and he said no. That to me seems like conditional love.
samueltyler2 · 80-89, M
I wish I could continue to chat, but I am exhausted and need to go to sleep. Read Herman Wouk's book "this is my God".