Why?

Okay, let's keep this civil. I want to know why owning a semiautomatic, military style firearm, with quick change magazines exceeding let's say 8 rounds, is so important to you. Why? What do you use it for that you could not otherwise do with something like a Henry Long Ranger.223 Remington, or let's say a Model 48 9mm S&W Revolver?

I have other questions concerning the whole firearms issue, but let's start with this.

Before you launch into a tirade, know that I started shooting at around the age of 10, am a combat veteran, a retired Mastersergeant, own and always have owned, at least one firearm, and support our 2nd Amendment. I sincerely want to know your reasoning.

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

Wraithorn · 51-55, M

I'm going to throw in my 2 cents even though I am not an American.
I live in South Africa and I was a policeman for 21 yrs. Civilians in S.A. are not allowed to own weapons like assault rifles because it is not necessary. Also, in most countries more innocent people are hurt by firearms that are kept for self defense than criminals.

The USA has possibly the biggest and best equiped military and police in the world. The civilians there do not need assault rifles etc. in order to defend themselves.
It's clearly a money making thing and placing the value of money above that of innocent Human life is just not right.

frequentlyme · 70-79, M

@Wraithorn Thanks for your response. I appreciate all thoughtful, civil responses. I'm trying to get a grip on the why - seems to be difficult for many to civilly and specifically state their reasoning.

Wraithorn · 51-55, M

@frequentlyme It's a pleasure. I think sometimes people's emotional attachment to things prevents them from being able to be civil.
American gun laws have become part of many people's culture there. People generally feel fear when their culture is threatened. When people are trioubled by fear it becomes difficult for them to be civil or reasonable.

Attachment can be the great facricator of illusions which prevents us from seeing truth.

frequentlyme · 70-79, M

@Wraithorn Absolutely correct; but the way through our fears is to face them.

Wraithorn · 51-55, M

@frequentlyme Good point !