Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Is it still the same river if every drop of water has been replaced?

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Cierzo · M
No. In fact, when a single drop is replaced, the river changes
Invisible · 26-30, M
@Cierzo: Is someone who gets a kidney transplant a different person?
Cierzo · M
@Invisible: The river does not have a conscience, it is pure matter.
We are no only matter, our conscience does not change if we get a kidney transplant. It is a change, but not an essential one.
Invisible · 26-30, M
If a man gets a brain lesion and can no longer speak, is he the same man? He can think all the same
Cierzo · M
@Invisible: I don't think we are totally the same we were a second ago.
I would not call that person a different one, since he can think all the same. However, if braon transplant was possible, someone would be a different person when receiving a new brain.