I have plenty of Reese's, but you would have to fight me for them

I`d dump the whole bag of peanut butter cups in your goodie bag. Nasty things..

Those little bags of chips: Potato chips, cheese curls, Fritos, sun chips, etc.

An invitation to come in and to have a coffee 🤗

Butterfingers

You can have anything but the Butterfingers!

Depends on the costume I imagine

Pffft, you're not getting my Reeses *throws an apple in your plastic pumpkin and slams the door*

I wouldn't be home?

Apples.

A concerned look and possibly a weapon. If you're out after dark in Africa, dressed as something scary, be prepared for incoming spears and arrows. Might wanna try not to stray so far from home next time too.

🙂🎃

Dum dums