Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I just don't get how we can have free will in a universe where God already knows what will happen because that means it was always going to happen. [Spirituality & Religion]

Your eyes saw me before I was put together. And all the days of my life were written in Your book before any of them came to be.
Psalms 139:16

If everything i'll ever do is written down before i'm even born, then how do i actually have free will rather than just the illusions that i am acting under free will along a path set before me?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
Not necessarily. He is all knowing which means, He knows from the beginning to end what will happen if mankind fell and if mankind didn't fall. Since the latter didn't happen, God made a plan to save mankind through His Son, Jesus Christ, by His Holy Spirit. Anyone who chooses to receive God's good gift of salvation will be saved.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
He is all knowing which means, He knows from the beginning to end what will happen if mankind fell and if mankind didn't fall.
So he would have known from the very beginning that mankind was going to fall. Put simply, Eve and Satan were set up.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
Put simply, Eve and Satan were set up.

Put simply, Adam and Eve were set up by Satan.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63 Not at all. If you believe the bible, Satan was just as much a victim of that set up as Eve was.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
Not at all. If you believe the bible, Satan was just as much a victim of that set up as Eve was.

I don't know what bible you read, but I read the Word of God (Holy Bible) and that's not how the account reads.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
I don't know what bible you read,
There are several different versions of it so it's clear the god thing couldn't get the story straight and you could be misinterpreting it too. The basic story is fairly simple though. "God" is said to know all, past present and future. Therefore, as it knew what was going to happen, Satan, Eve and, later, Adam had no power to affect the outcome. Doing so would have proveen god wrong and we can't allow that can we?
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
There are several different versions of it so it's clear the god thing couldn't get the story straight and you could be misinterpreting it too. The basic story is fairly simple though.

Wrong again. There are different translation but His Word never changes.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
There are different translation but the His Word never changes.
Why are there different versions in each language then? If "his word" never changes, there should only be one version in each language.

Even then it would still rely on you interpreting it correctly - which it appears you don't.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
Why are there different versions in each language then?

Don't you know?
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
Don't you know?
Yes, it's because they're a collection of fairy stories translated by different people. I just thought you might have a different explanation.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
Yes, it's because they're a collection of fairy stories translated by different people

Prove it.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
Prove it.
Already have, many time. Others have too. It's not our fault you're incapable of understanding the proof. You can't prove they're not just fairy stories.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
Already have, many time.

Where?
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
Where?
In several threads but, as I said, you're not able to understand the proof.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
In several threads but, as I said, you're not able to understand the proof

Not proof enough.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
Not proof enough.
Prove it! The proof was clear enough, you just couldn't understand it no matter how simple I made it for you. I even used the same methods and standard you use but to no avail.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
Prove it!

Yahweh already did.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
Yahweh already did.
Where?
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
Where?

In the threads on here.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63
In the threads on here.
You're lying. No one by that name has an account on this site. Try again and be truthful next time.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
You're lying.

Tell yourself that.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63 I'm telling you that. Anyone here can look at "People" on this site and quickly ascertain that no one by the name "yahweh" is or has been a member. The closest is @YahwehKhan but her don't appear to support anything you say either.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
I'm telling you that.

You'd be lying then, Sharon.
Sharon · F
@GodSpeed63 No, you're lying. Denying that fact when the evidence is clear for eveyone to see just makes you look stupid as well as being a liar. Anyone who doubts I'm telling the truth when I say there is no member of this site called "yahweh" can easily check for themselves.
GodSpeed63 · 70-79, M
@Sharon
No, you're lying.

Whatever. 🙄