Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I just don't get how we can have free will in a universe where God already knows what will happen because that means it was always going to happen. [Spirituality & Religion]

Your eyes saw me before I was put together. And all the days of my life were written in Your book before any of them came to be.
Psalms 139:16

If everything i'll ever do is written down before i'm even born, then how do i actually have free will rather than just the illusions that i am acting under free will along a path set before me?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
If you are truly interested, I can try to explain. But if all you (or others) want to do is argue and ridicule beliefs, I haven't got the time for that kind of nonsense.
@PrivateHell

No go ahead. And please don't mistake any pushback as ridicule. I'm interested in discussing this topic.
@Pikachu okay, the best way to reconcile these two issues is by comparing it to a parent with their teen children...

Let's say you have a sixteen year old son who is just starting to drive on his own. Now, you have taught him the proper rules of the road and warned him against bad driving behaviors while training him to drive. Still, he doesn't seem to listen, and chooses to go everywhere at 90 mph, while getting drunk or high with his friends because he's young and doesn't think anything will happen to him.

When you are not in the car with him, you don't control his every action. But if you tell him he is going to kill himself or someone else, or you tell him he will get pulled over and suffer those consequences, are you merely guessing? Or do you know that eventually these are the most likely outcomes? And does it mean that it is carved in stone for him, or can he change?

When we say God knows every beat of your heart and blink of your eye, we are not saying He knows exactly what you will choose to do each second. We are saying He knows each choice you are faced with and how those decisions will end no matter which way you decide. The choice is still up to you.
@PrivateHell

But if i was always going to make that choice (because god couldn't be wrong about what i was going to choose) then was it really a choice? If the end is already known then what possibility is there to take a different choice?

I guess to me it's the foreknowledge of it that makes it seem like predetermination rather than a record of choices.
@Pikachu you are faced with option "A" or option "B". God knows you well enough to know that you will most likely choose "B", and He already knows that if you do "XYZ" will happen. But, if for some reason you choose option "A" then He knows that "ABC" will happen. Knowing all this doesn't mean you don't have a choice. It just means He already knows the outcome no matter what you decide.

I hope this helps. And thanks for remaining civil.
@PrivateHell

Thanks. I'm not sure that it convinces me but it is a notion to ponder.