Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Yoga is Demonic? [Spirituality & Religion]

A view held by many conservative Christians is that yoga is "demonic". Without discrediting the argument with the "all religion is fake" counterclaim, can you give your position on the topic and why?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
There's nothing wrong with meditation, however, it's important to consider a variety of aspects about this practice. When we begin to meditate, right away, our mind becomes wide open to receive any and all types of spiritual forces, no matter whether we attempt to empty our mind of thoughts, or simply repeat a mantra. That's why it's important how you meditate.

Idling is dangerous. When we have nothing to do, our mind can turn to negative or evil thoughts. It goes from thoughts to words, then sometimes actions which may prove to be consequential. That is why it is said that an idle mind is the devil’s workshop. Depression feeds on negative thoughts, beliefs or behaviors. All in all, quite a lousy cycle. Keeping yourself occupied is difficult for many, and many fall prey to the cycle. It is seen frequently.

Proverbs 16:27 Idle hands are the devil’s workshop; idle lips are his mouthpiece, literally, “A worthless man devises mischief; and in his lips there is a scorching fire.”

Something to consider is a study published in 2017 on the negative effects of meditation, led by Dr. Willoughby Britton, Professor of Psychiatry and Human Behaviour at Brown University: 82% reported fear, anxiety panic, and paranoia. 57% reported depression, dysphoria, or grief. 50% reported social impairment. 47% reported delusional, irrational, or paranormal beliefs. 47% reported physical pain. 42% reported occupational impairment. 30% reported rage, anger, or aggression. 27% reported sleep disorder. 25% reported self-conscious emotions and insecurity. And 17% said that they experienced something so severe that it required inpatient hospitalization. Most people reported these symptoms lasting months to years, and these regular long-term effects seem to be more congruent with psychological breakdowns and disorders, than with enlightenment.

Transcendental meditation is harmful, as it deceives the meditators into believing they are God, and those who believe they are God, are God’s enemies for they are full of pride.

Second, transcendental meditation's purpose is to induce the meditator to contact demons (that is, to see demons, to talk with them, to invite them in his life), which are evil spirits which live in the air and are ready to hurt people by oppressing or possessing them. The meditator is encouraged to invoke demons by repeating mantras. A mantra is a sound symbol of one or more syllables used to induce a mystical state. Thus the mantra both invites a particular being (demon) to enter the one using it, and also creates the passive state in the meditator to facilitate this fusion of beings. Therefore mantras are not meaningless sounds that bring about deep rest, as TM teachers say to the meditators, but words addressed to demons which are invited to enter the meditator. This is nothing to get mixed in with.

What should we think about when we meditate?

God does want us to meditate, but not the way most think. David gives insight as to when to meditate: “But his delight is in the law of the Lord; and in His law does he meditate day and night ” ( Psa. 1:1-2 ). He also stated, “O how I love your law! It is my meditation all the day."

This verse in God's Word is included for a reason. He knows the power and influence from the dark side of the spiritual realm. A safer way to meditate:

Philippians 4:8 - " Therefore, my brethren, whatsoever things that are true, those that are honorable, those that are righteous, those things that are pure, those things that are precious, those things that are praiseworthy, deeds of glory and of praise, meditate/think on these things."

I know some cancer patients are directed to meditation to help manage pain, along with prayer. The mind is a powerful tool in pain management. I don't feel God would be opposed to that.
InvictusIndigo · 22-25, M
@LadyGrace I might not be the most perfect person, and I'm most-definitely not the best christian in the world either, but this is really refreshing. This stance piqued my interest because I am a student at a christian university. I am a music student and one of our classes has us doing yoga once a week in order to stretch and relax and de-stress, but I heard that one of the music teachers is opposed to the idea of doing yoga because "It's not christian". This helps to put things into perspective, thank you.
JimboSaturn · 51-55, M
I think the good or bad in something depends on what it creates. I have never hear of people practicing yoga or meditation to commit more evil acts or have more negative feelings than others; to the contrary. @LadyGrace
InvictusIndigo · 22-25, M
@JimboSaturn @LadyGrace This is true, I also haven't heard of it before. Could we get more info on that study?
JimboSaturn · 51-55, M
When I have meditated, I felt very spiritual and at one with the universe and God. Because I felt one with everything, I felt compassion and love. My mind was devoid of petty evil thoughts. Yoga just makes me feel well stretched and relaxed. I believe clearing your mind is not idleness at all, it actually takes a lot of discipline and self control. But that is just my experience.@InvictusIndigo
@JimboSaturn Right. Neither have I and that was not what I was saying.
JimboSaturn · 51-55, M
But it sounds like you are saying that could happen, I just don't agree with that. @LadyGrace
@JimboSaturn Exactly what could happen? why would somebody practice yoga in order to do evil? I'm beginning to think you have misunderstood my whole response.
JimboSaturn · 51-55, M
You said that meditation opens you up to evil spirits and makes you idyl and think you are godlike. You support only your particular way of meditating. I disagree that only your ways of meditation is beneficial. @LadyGrace
@JimboSaturn I never said my ways of meditation are beneficial, nor even if I meditate. What I said was, when we begin to meditate, right away, our mind becomes wide open to receive any and all types of spiritual forces, no matter whether we attempt to empty our mind of thoughts, or simply repeat a mantra. That's why it's important [u]how[/u] you meditate. I also said an idle mind is not good. All types of thoughts can come in. The article I got the facts from in the study, was so lengthy, I was not able to include it all. Thus, that could be why it feels incomplete. Dr. Willoughby Britton, Professor of Psychiatry and Human Behaviour at Brown University, was extremely thorough in her study. She has also been a committed mindfulness practitioner for 20 years. She says, “A lot of psychological material is going to come up and be processed. Old resentments, wounds, that kind of thing,” says Britton, “But also some traumatic material if people have a trauma history, it can come up and need additional support or even therapy.” Some of Britton’s research is making headway into understanding “difficult or challenging mind states” among advanced meditators and scholars that can occur as a result of intensive meditation practice. My personal conclusions come from God's inerrant Word. According to scripture, Satan has his subtle ways of presenting idleness or meditation as harmless. No one has to believe that, but I do. To each their own.
@InvictusIndigo I couldn't say "it's not Christian". After all, David and others meditated in the bible. God's Word, as I mentioned in my statement, tells us how to do it.

God does want us to meditate, but not the way most think. David gives insight as to when to meditate: “But his delight is in the law of the Lord; and in His law does he meditate day and night ” ( Psa. 1:1-2 ). He also stated, “O how I love your law! It is my meditation all the day."
JimboSaturn · 51-55, M
So you are saying that some meditation can cause leaving your mind open to bad things. You contradict yourself.@LadyGrace
@JimboSaturn I've never contradicted myself. Read my [b]whole[/b] first response to the poster. Or else you're misinterpreting my responses. I said it depends on HOW you meditate. It's in the bible.