I have a suggestion for SW

Why is the only honour an OP can bestow on a comment "Best"? Comments can be an awful lot more. I would have posters be given the option to mark comments as:
• Most interesting
• Most challenging: in a good way, of course
• Funniest
• Most constructive
And I'd also want razzie awards:
• Most dishonest
• Most crass
• Most unforgivable
• And my top priority: Most irrelevant: I'd be giving this one all the time! Nobody who comments on my posts manages to stay on topic! For that reason, I want to rank them! The top 10 most irrelevant comments on my posts!

I think I might pin this one.

Top | New | Old

Queendragonfly · 31-35, F

I don't like to be able ranking funniest because I like that several people can equally comment fun things from different perspectives.

I like most challenging it would be a great one next to the best tag, but the rest feels a bit much and strangles the comment section.

Pinkstarburst · F

Or…the OP can just tell the person those things in a reply. Marking “Best Comment” is a way for the commenter to get coins. I’m not even sure many realize that or even use the button.

It’s better to just interact with folks…not just press a stupid button.

View 1 more replies »

Pinkstarburst · F

@ImperialAerosolKidFromEP It’s to give people coins. I’m not a best comment giver. I don’t look at replies as a contest. I enjoy the interaction that a post brings.

But I also don’t post Q&A much

OogieBoogie · F

@Pinkstarburst I agree....words are more meaningful.
I also rarely use the 'best comment' thing unless one comment really stands out above all the rest.

Pinkstarburst · F

@OogieBoogie I honestly forget it’s even there.

tallpowerhouseblonde · 36-40, F

I like your Idea.One vote yes from me.

SW-User

@MethDozer already claimed Worst Comment

bijouxbroussard · F

@SW-User Which is just more negativity, like the downvote. 🙁

SW-User

@bijouxbroussard it's his little joke I think, knowing it'd never fly. The downvote seems to have lost some steam in the comments.

Add a comment...