Fun
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I may lose my friends, family, and even my job over this, but it needs to be said

A hot dog [b]IS[/b] a sandwich

I might be a little late to the debate, but I recently watched a video from a professor talking about how informal experiments showed him that even something as simple as whether or not a hot dog was a sandwich caused participants to devolve into the typical destructive patterns we see in tribalism. Battle lines were drawn, passions escalated, and people who were previously neutral to one another now looked at each other in bewilderment. It's an amusing and interesting observation that depicts, rather unfortunately, a microcosm of the human experience.

But since it was posed, I decided to give some thought to the question of: is a hot dog a sandwich?

To answer that, you would first need to understand what a sandwich even is. Is it necessary to have more than once piece of bread? What about hoagies or subs that only split one piece of bread wide enough to stuff the fillings into it? In that case, would a jelly doughnut or chocolate éclair count as a sandwich since it's basically bread with filling stuffed into it?

Or conversely, if I fold a singular slice of bread in half, does that mean I have an air sandwich? Does the actual type of filling determine what a sandwich is? Or does the type of bread determine whether or not it's a sandwich? Would an ice cream sandwich still be a sandwich? Or an Oreo still a sandwich cookie? Is a quesadilla just a Mexican grilled cheese?

I've taken it upon myself to travel the world in search for the answers. I've spoken with hundreds of religious leaders, government officials, business executives, university professors, clinical physicians, technology experts, scientific researchers, prominent thinkers, professional wrestlers, amateur film makers, babbling toddlers, and their easily-outraged mothers, and one thing became unanimously and universally true: these were stupid f*cking questions.

But as I was thinking about it, I realized that a sandwich is not just a thing you eat, it's also a verb. You can eat a sandwich, but you can also sandwich something by enclosing it between something else. It's like how painting is also a verb and a noun. If I drew with crayons onto a canvas, it would not qualify as a painting because the portrait was not painted onto there. It's instead a drawing. And just as there are many different types of sandwiches, there are different types of paintings. I can paint using a brush, using my fingers, using someone else's severed fingers, using a computer program, or using other objects like sponges or rollers or even sandwiches themselves. The end result is still a painting.

So if I lay on a couch, I can become sandwiched between two pillows. If I motorboat someone, my face can become sandwiched between their fun-bags. Likewise, you can sandwich a hot dog wiener between the two sides of the hot dog bun, thus making a hot dog a sandwich.

Anyways, thanks for attending my TED Talk

This comment is hidden. Show Comment
TinyViolins · 31-35, M
@jshm2 So then is a hoagie or sub sandwich not a sandwich since the bread is still intact?
Doomflower · 36-40, M
I argue that pizza is a sandwich.

Open faced sandwiches exist. Therefore pizza is an open faced sandwich. A calzone is the closed version.
TinyViolins · 31-35, M
@Doomflower What are you, a communist? Open faced sandwiches are just incomplete sandwiches. They don't count. It's just a lazy way of cutting carbs or an unfortunate case of running out of ingredients. It's like calling a pot of plain noodles mac & cheese. You're missing something.

Where does it end? Is a slice of toast with butter on it a sandwich? Are cheese and crackers a sandwich? Is a doughnut simply an open-faced sugar sandwich? What does that make a cinnamon bun?

If you folded a slice of pizza in half, it would be a different story, since you would be physically sandwiching the toppings in between dough. But as is? No way.
Doomflower · 36-40, M
@TinyViolins Your logic cuts both ways!! In such case tacos and burritos are sandwiches too! Does anything encased in bread now count? Are pot pies sandwiches!? Is a jelly filled donut now a sandwich?

Toast is toast. Avocado toast is not an open faced sandwich but an open sandwich may contain avocado.
TinyViolins · 31-35, M
@Doomflower Well it's very generous of you to presume I have logic, but those are the questions that makes the debate tricky. There's the actual concept of the sandwich as something with bread, meat, and cheese, and then there are things inspired by that idea and made to resemble a sandwich, or maybe something comes from a different culture that has a lot of overlapping characteristics that either get accepted as a sandwich variant or categorized as something different altogether.

People all over the world used cooked dough as a vehicle to shove as much food down our gullet as possible by using it as a containment device. You have your traditional meat and cheese sandwich in between two slices of bread, but you also have other things that muddy the water, like gyros, flatbread sandwiches, wraps, tacos, hamburgers, and hot dogs. In the abstract sense, you can categorize all of those things as sandwiches since they all use bread as a containment device for different toppings.

Remember back when KFC took two fried chicken breasts and stuffed a half pound of lard in between and then called that a sandwich? It's common for people to use different foods and smash them together in order to mimic a sandwich, like in my example of sandwiching the pizza toppings in between the dough. If an idea like that takes off, people generally accept it as a type of sandwich tangential to what people commonly think of as a sandwich, like a Philly cheesesteak or a PB&J or a breakfast sandwich

Maybe the hidden variable this whole time has been the fact that baked bread was already a thing that existed, and people would have to slice the bread in order to add the fillings of their choice into it. Like if you put all the taco ingredients in between sliced bread, you would basically get a torta, which more neatly fits the concept of a sandwich. Whereas if you took all your typical sandwich ingredients and put it into a tortilla, people would just call that a wrap.

Since a hot dog relies on sliced bread in order to secure the sausage in place, it's probably far more of a sandwich than people give it credit for. Basically, if bread needs to be sliced in order to create containment between the slices, the end result is probably sandwich irrespective of the fillings
Aidan · 26-30
Piper · 61-69, F
Technically, a hot dog [i]does[/i] qualify as sandwich. Most would hope, though, that a hot dog does not contain any parts of a [b]dog[/b]. 🥺
You have just uncorked fury that cannot be imagined or ever contained again. I hope this was worth it. 🤪
10liters · 31-35, M
Just came for the comments. didnt read anytning but the title.
I lost it all and have nothing to lose. That includes my life which I don’t care about losing.
There's a little time I thought would be better spent...

 
Post Comment