I Received Corporal Punishment At School

when being caned at schoolmy oldest son was twice given a choice, something i did not approve of and never did as a deputy. WITH THE same cane and being used with the same force he was given the choice, twice, of six strokes across just his underpants or four on his bare bottom. The first time he was nearly 12 and the second nearly 13.

Of course i know what he selected but am curious as to which of the two you would have choosen and nore important the reason.

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

barney1 · M

for me it would have been 4 on the bare , because that way i owuld have got 2 less strokes

NortiusMaximus · M

@barney1 Same here. I asked my wife and she said the same. We both got the cane on the bare at home.

Sharon · F

@barney1 @NortiusMaximus I'd choose four on the bare too. Knickers/underpants don't offer any real protection, certainly not enough to make it worth having two more strokes.

barney1 · M

@Sharon i think its quite a an easy choice really, like you say sharon the lack of protection far outweighs the 2 extra strokes, and to be honest a bare bottom didnt worry me that much if it meant 2 less strokes