Easy to debunk the story of Adam and Eve

The story of Adam and Eve is very easily debunked. Consider the following. If God is perfect and has always been perfect. And has never had the freedom of choice to be perfect or imperfect. Then why did God make Adam and Eve imperfect and give them the freedom of choice? Why didn't God make Adam and Eve perfect like himself? Making them imperfect and giving them the freedom of choice is not necessary. To create beings to suffer is evil.

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

SW-User

God is whole. This is what it says in the Tanakh, the Old Testament. If he had not given Adam and Eve free will, he would be a dictator. Suffering is necessary.

What is good without evil? Does it mean anything when there is no evil?

SinlessOnslaught · M

@SW-User He gave us free will.

Pfuzylogic · M

@SW-User In Genesis, when God created the Universe, he stated after “It is good”.
Look at Genesis 1:4 after the creation of light, Genesis 1:10 after the separation of the water from the firmaments, Genesis 10:12 yielding of seed and so on through out Genesis dealing with creation.
There was no dependency on evil.