Are guys still attracted to girls with tomboy personalities or is that a turn off?

When I was a kid - there was a girl in our little gang that played sports w/us, etc. All the other girls made fun of her. When we got a little older we kissed on a dare....and nothing was the same...it got weird. In some odd turn of events I met her years later and she's now gay (she told me) and I asked her "was my kiss really that bad????"....she laughed (thankfully!). The end.