Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

What if Trump was a Democrat

I read an article in The Atlantic by David Brooks called “Why Do So Many People Think That Trump is Good?”. Brooks draws on the philosophy of Alasdaire MacIntyre, saying that modern society has lost its sense of right and wrong, so our morality now is based on our personal preferences. He goes on to caution Democrats against getting too self-righteous, saying that if Trump was on our team most of us would love him too.

I would particularly appreciate responses from people who have read the article, but my questions are as follows: if Trump were a Democrat, what would that even look like? The whole “Do whatever the heck you want and you shouldn’t have to give a shit how it affects others” philosophy is on the Republican side, Democrats are against that. We’re in favor of social responsibility. So how could most Democrats “love Trump if he were on our team”?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
KGH68 · 61-69, FNew
I read the article but as always with David Brooks I end up frustrated and seriously annoyed. His entire piece is flawed as he idealizes Macintyre and indeed the Greeks ignoring the complications of morality and its relationship to modernity. Democrats would not love Trump and he would never be on our team - he's about cruelty and power - and for all its flaws the modern Democratic Party has been about trying to do the right thing for the majority of people. Civil Rights, Women's Rights, giving a voice to the little guy/gal.