Twice-deported illegal alien drove drunk past 18 cars before killing college hockey captain
Ryan O’Shea was 21 years old, captain of his college hockey team, and preparing for a career in law enforcement. He wanted to become a New York City police officer, a dream his family and professors say reflected his desire to help other people.
On October 16, that future ended on a Connecticut highway.
Now newly detailed court records reveal that the man accused of killing him allegedly drove past at least 18 vehicles while traveling the wrong way on Interstate 91. Police say Guillermo Carmona-Lopez, 31, was drunk, had a suspended driver’s license, and had already been deported from the United States twice.
And somehow, he was back behind the wheel on an American highway.
Surveillance footage showed Carmona-Lopez traveling against traffic before his Chevrolet Silverado struck O’Shea’s Honda Accord head-on near Exit 9 in North Haven shortly before midnight.
The impact sent O’Shea’s car into additional collisions involving two other vehicles. The young college student died at the scene, while other people involved in the crash suffered injuries.
Investigators say the evidence paints a disturbing picture of what happened before the collision.
According to the arrest warrant, Carmona-Lopez told authorities that he had consumed four 12-ounce bottles of Modelo beer within approximately one hour. Hospital blood tests subsequently showed alcohol concentrations of 0.21% and 0.22%.
Connecticut’s legal limit is 0.08%.
Those readings were approaching three times the limit, and Carmona-Lopez was allegedly driving with a license that had been suspended since May 24, 2024, following an earlier DUI arrest.
That alone raises serious questions about why he was driving. But his immigration history adds another dimension to the case.
According to Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Carmona-Lopez is a Mexican national who was removed from the United States twice in 2013 after entering the country illegally.
Federal authorities say Border Patrol agents first apprehended him in May of that year, leading to an expedited removal. He subsequently entered again near the Rio Grande Valley and was arrested a second time.
An immigration judge issued another removal order on May 30, 2013.
ICE says he later returned to the United States again, although the date and location of that entry remain unknown. By October 2026, authorities say he was living in Connecticut.
Which brings us back to the most troubling question in this case: How does someone removed from the country twice end up driving on an American interstate with a suspended license and an alleged blood alcohol level nearly three times the legal limit?
Connecticut State Police arrested Carmona-Lopez on November 9 after he spent several weeks hospitalized with serious injuries from the crash.
He now faces 13 charges, including second-degree manslaughter, manslaughter with a motor vehicle, operating under the influence, reckless driving, driving with a suspended license and wrong-way driving on a divided highway. The charges also include three counts each of third-degree assault and first-degree reckless endangerment.
He is being held on a $500,000 bond, with his next court appearance scheduled for December 1.
On October 16, that future ended on a Connecticut highway.
Now newly detailed court records reveal that the man accused of killing him allegedly drove past at least 18 vehicles while traveling the wrong way on Interstate 91. Police say Guillermo Carmona-Lopez, 31, was drunk, had a suspended driver’s license, and had already been deported from the United States twice.
And somehow, he was back behind the wheel on an American highway.
Surveillance footage showed Carmona-Lopez traveling against traffic before his Chevrolet Silverado struck O’Shea’s Honda Accord head-on near Exit 9 in North Haven shortly before midnight.
The impact sent O’Shea’s car into additional collisions involving two other vehicles. The young college student died at the scene, while other people involved in the crash suffered injuries.
Investigators say the evidence paints a disturbing picture of what happened before the collision.
According to the arrest warrant, Carmona-Lopez told authorities that he had consumed four 12-ounce bottles of Modelo beer within approximately one hour. Hospital blood tests subsequently showed alcohol concentrations of 0.21% and 0.22%.
Connecticut’s legal limit is 0.08%.
Those readings were approaching three times the limit, and Carmona-Lopez was allegedly driving with a license that had been suspended since May 24, 2024, following an earlier DUI arrest.
That alone raises serious questions about why he was driving. But his immigration history adds another dimension to the case.
According to Immigration and Customs Enforcement, Carmona-Lopez is a Mexican national who was removed from the United States twice in 2013 after entering the country illegally.
Federal authorities say Border Patrol agents first apprehended him in May of that year, leading to an expedited removal. He subsequently entered again near the Rio Grande Valley and was arrested a second time.
An immigration judge issued another removal order on May 30, 2013.
ICE says he later returned to the United States again, although the date and location of that entry remain unknown. By October 2026, authorities say he was living in Connecticut.
Which brings us back to the most troubling question in this case: How does someone removed from the country twice end up driving on an American interstate with a suspended license and an alleged blood alcohol level nearly three times the legal limit?
Connecticut State Police arrested Carmona-Lopez on November 9 after he spent several weeks hospitalized with serious injuries from the crash.
He now faces 13 charges, including second-degree manslaughter, manslaughter with a motor vehicle, operating under the influence, reckless driving, driving with a suspended license and wrong-way driving on a divided highway. The charges also include three counts each of third-degree assault and first-degree reckless endangerment.
He is being held on a $500,000 bond, with his next court appearance scheduled for December 1.


