This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
pdockal · 56-60, M
As of late January 2026, these laws have not yet been enacted or survived a court challenge. Legal experts predict that if passed, they will face immediate lawsuits from the U.S. Department of Justice to determine if a state can legally use its hiring power to effectively "blacklist" federal employees.
The constitutionality of blocking ICE agents from holding state jobs is a complex legal issue that remains largely untested in court as of January 2026. While specific bills like Maryland’s "Icebreaker Act of 2026" have been introduced, legal experts are divided on whether they would survive a constitutional challenge.
The Supremacy Clause: Opponents argue states cannot legally "penalize" or discriminate against individuals for performing federally authorized duties.
Intergovernmental Immunity: This doctrine prevents states from regulating the federal government or its employees in a way that interferes with federal operations.
Bill of Attainder: Critics suggest that targeting a specific group of people for a lifetime employment ban without a trial may be unconstitutional.
The constitutionality of blocking ICE agents from holding state jobs is a complex legal issue that remains largely untested in court as of January 2026. While specific bills like Maryland’s "Icebreaker Act of 2026" have been introduced, legal experts are divided on whether they would survive a constitutional challenge.
The Supremacy Clause: Opponents argue states cannot legally "penalize" or discriminate against individuals for performing federally authorized duties.
Intergovernmental Immunity: This doctrine prevents states from regulating the federal government or its employees in a way that interferes with federal operations.
Bill of Attainder: Critics suggest that targeting a specific group of people for a lifetime employment ban without a trial may be unconstitutional.
@pdockal A good smack-back would be for congress to exempt federal employees in that state from all state and local taxes.
pdockal · 56-60, M
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
PicturesOfABetterTomorrow · 41-45, M
@pdockal Lol. Figures you would be shilling for other agencies to be forced to accept piss poor recruits for feelings.
pdockal · 56-60, M
@PicturesOfABetterTomorrow
Nobody is being forced
But blocking them without any hearing is childish which you seem to support
Unless you can produce actual data/numbers your just being immature because you like illegals over citizens
Nobody is being forced
But blocking them without any hearing is childish which you seem to support
Unless you can produce actual data/numbers your just being immature because you like illegals over citizens
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
pdockal · 56-60, M
@PicturesOfABetterTomorrow
You don't even know the proposed law
It's about state government agencies NOT being allowed to hire any person who was gainfully employed working for he federal government
Critics argue that barring individuals based solely on their previous lawful employment is a form of viewpoint discrimination and could violate equal protection clauses. Legal experts suggest that such measures, which target employees based on the administration under which they served, could face successful legal challenge
But you would be supporting this
It's a slippery slope
Think about how it will backfire
Next they will block what group of people ?
Didn't think you were this uneducated and misinformed
You don't even know the proposed law
It's about state government agencies NOT being allowed to hire any person who was gainfully employed working for he federal government
Critics argue that barring individuals based solely on their previous lawful employment is a form of viewpoint discrimination and could violate equal protection clauses. Legal experts suggest that such measures, which target employees based on the administration under which they served, could face successful legal challenge
But you would be supporting this
It's a slippery slope
Think about how it will backfire
Next they will block what group of people ?
Didn't think you were this uneducated and misinformed
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment
This comment is hidden.
Show Comment






