Random
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Republicans excuses for why renewable energy is “evil”

Wind turbines kill birds!!! - Fossil fuels kill 20x more.

Wind turbines can’t be recycled!! - Yes they can

Solar panels can’t be recycled!! - Yes they can

Offshore wind hurts whales!! - No it doesn’t, but seismic blasting for oil and gas does.

Are you on their payroll? Why are you unthinkingly parroting Big Oil’s propaganda?
Top | New | Old
Nanoose · 70-79, M
The Canadian province I live in generates 100% it’s energy from renewable energy. I pay an average of $60 for 2 months energy (heat, lights and cooking). Last year BC hydro gave me and 1000’s of other BC residents free energy efficient air conditioners (bet the big oil companies don’t do stuff like that). Cheers!
ArishMell · 70-79, M
Wind turbines, or rather, their materials not the objects, can be salvaged but not entirely.

- The metals, yes, by re-melting them (needing a lot of energy).

- The blades no: Those are made at least partly from synthetic composite materials such as carbon-fibre reinforced resin.

The composites include synthetic-resin bonded paper and fabric, and the thermosetting plastics ('Bakelite' and its modern versions); and the vast tonnage of glass-fibre that has accummulated over the decades in buildings, boats, vehicles, and many luxury items. The last too, in both raw fibrous form (mainly building insulation) and resin-bonded mouldings (e.g. boat hulls, flat roofs).

About the only possible use for such material when scrapped would be granulating it to form a filler for new types of mouldings. I do not know if this can be, or is, done.

The resin itself of course, is made from.... petroleum derivatives. As are the electrical insulating materials, the hydraulic and lubricating oils, and the protective paints, all necessary in wind-turbines.

====

Solar Panels? The glass and the metals are salvageable. I am not sure about the active materials; nor how recoverable are the materials in the accompanying battery-banks.

====

Offshore wind-turbines' effect on animals? I think the difficulty is not that of deafening or frightening marine animals as seismic charges can by simple acoustic intensity, but of disturbing them by continual background noise interfering with or masking their calls. So not "hurting" them by injury but by affecting their normal behaviour.

'''''
Oh, and for the record I wrote that from basic, lay-level, general engineering and science knowledge. I do not work for either the petroleum or "green-energy" industry, and vote neither Republican nor Democrat. I am not even American.
meJess · F
Would be better if they said the wind doesn’t always blow, it confuses the navigation of migratory birds and interferes with radio and video signals.

Then to point out that solar is inefficient and uses materials provided under working conditions that do not meet human rights. Same with the battery farms that often go with them.

All energy options have issues.
@meJess Do you have anything to add to my answer, which has shot you down?
meJess · F
@wishforthenight your answer only confirms how unreliable wind energy is. Which was my original point.
@meJess LOL

You keep saying “wind is unreliable” like the grid hasn’t been running on variable inputs for decades.

Spoiler: demand isn’t constant either, yet somehow the lights stay on.

Engineers figured this out a long time ago. You can too, if you stop confusing variability with unreliability.
Charity · 61-69
👍👏👏

 
Post Comment