Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Australia to give away free electricity – and it sounds legit. How much would 273,000 GwH cost?




Photo above - the Peak Downs coal mine in Australia, one of the largest on Earth. Australia just announced plans to give away free electricity from solar panels.

The land down under (Oz, Australia) has 80 BILLION tons of coal. Guess what they have more of? Sunlight. The nation’s pivot to solar panels is paying off. There’s so much solar power, the government plans to offer free solar electricity (see link below).

Of course, there’s a catch. It’s only free when the sun is shining. But still . . . sounds good to me.

There’s a bunch of other fine print which Aussies will probably ignore while playing with their Fosters and Rambo knives, too. The “sunlight” rule apparently applies only to PEAK daylight, when solar rays are crashing down vertically. Not midmorning, or late afternoon, when shadows are longer. And then there’s something called “negative wholesale rates”, which sounds especially diabolical. But still . . .

The obvious next question is – can we buy a battery to store this peak/free electricity to use during the other 20 hours a day? Yes we can – but those things aren’t free. Elon Musk sold Australia the world's largest battery array a few years ago. But that gear is waaaay expensive, and the government hasn’t come back for a re-order. Homeowners might be a better target for some casket sized battery pack that fits in the laundry room.

How much does a Tesla Powerwall cost? When you ask Amazon, they claim to have “100 results” but none of the products are actually Powerwalls made by Tesla. Most are car charging stations.

Copilot found a Powerwall 3 on sale for $15,400, including shipping, handling, and installation (probably not to Australia though). That’s $1,140 per KwH of storage. Will you need more than 13.39 KwH per day, in the 20 hours when government solar power isn’t free? I’ll leave that question to readers with advanced math degrees. Also, any questions about the half-life of a Powerwall, as it’s battery gradually sheds capacity while time goes by. But still . . .

Cheaper batteries are needed. They don’t necessarily need to use the popular lithium-ion-cadmium-manganese-unobtanium recipe, which relies on slave labor to extract rare earths from African pit mines. EV car batteries are only expensive because they need to be petite enough so your car won’t take a half hour to go from zero to 60. If you’re installing a home battery in your basement, it could weigh 8 tons instead of 800 pounds, and you wouldn’t care.

Someone could write a 2,000-word column on “non-EV batteries.” Things like pumping water back up INTO lakes, to turn the turbines later. Or concrete weights suspended from gears. Superheated liquid brine mixes.

The good news is that solar is going to provide free electrons, 4 hours a day, in Australia. What does Australia plan to do with all the coal they no longer need to burn? Probably sell it to China and India, which use as much coal annually as the entire rest of planet Earth combined.

I’m just sayin’ . . .




Australia has so much solar that it's offering everyone free electricity

The Actual Cost of a Tesla Powerwall: Is it Worth it? (2025 Data)
Top | New | Old
meJess · F
Negative wholesale rates are when the power is generated but the grid doesn’t have sufficient consumers. Not sure how that happens but they pay you to take the excess kilowatts. Happens with wind farms, maybe there is no off switch,.
SusanInFlorida · 31-35, F
@meJess what happens when consumer take "the excess kilowatts"? does that electricity actually keep the lights burning, or the AC on, if there's already too much electricity?
meJess · F
@SusanInFlorida if they take the excess then there is no excess, I think some firms and maybe homes charge vehicles etc when they see a negative wholesale rate. If I understand correctly, some of the smart systems give you cost on a hour by hour basis. Not claiming expertise but have read of it happening in European wind farms.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
The use of pumping water into higher reservoirs has been proven for a long time, too.

In the UK at least it is used as a peak-demand "extra" feed to the National Grid, with the pumps returning the water at dead of night when demand drops.
GerOttman · 70-79, M
@ArishMell I worked at one of those once! Really interesting facility.
NeoNeo · 46-50, M
@ArishMell Bidirectional meter system measures electricity generated by solar panels and transmitted to national grid, it also measures your local consumption which comes to your house from national grid.

You get consumption bill as well as details of power generated and you pay difference of that if your consumption is more than units generated otherwise you get credits.


Here idea is not to use solar power directly for your premises.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@NeoNeo I see. Thankyou for explaining it.

The system introduced in the UK and I think some other countries encouraged home owners to have solar panels on their own rooves. The electronics within the house measured the relative amounts of public- and private- supply, and could feed "surplus" electricity back into the mains, for which a so-called "Feed-in tariff" was available.

The "surplus" is typically that generated in daylight when the householders are all out and the only draw is by low-power appliances like the 'fridge and freezer.

Solar power is not suitable for all homes, particularly if the roof faces East and West rather than N-S, and of course not everyone can afford it. For those it would work, the system would eventually repay the installation and even make a profit, depending obviously on the way the household uses electricity.

I don't know if this still applies. The Feed-In Tariff has now been stopped, but the solar panels still help keep electricity costs down for those using them over a sufficiently long time.


The electricity and gas bills here (UK) are high, partly because they include a tax used by the Government to subsidise solar and wind power stations feeding the National Grid. Also of course because these utilities were privatised, they have a large profit element of which much is lost to the nation by foreign owners! Natural-gas is also subject to the highly irregular pricing of international hydrocarbons trading.


So we do not try to differentiate between what is supplied by the generators to the National Grid, and what is supplied to individual customers. We customers pay what we draw from the mains, irrespective of the mix of generating systems, but the price is set by the retailer and in turn the wholesale price.

.

All solar-power installations here use large storage batteries. The British Isles go Pole-wards from about 50ºN - higher latitude than Tasmania - so Winter brings low-angled sunshine and longer dark than daylight hours, as well as chilly weather. Even in daylight, in cloudy conditions the efficiency of photovoltaic arrays drops considerably.


My brother lives at nearly 56ºN, in Southern Scotland, and has built his own PV set!

The array itself is only about a metre square but set at the appropriate latitude angle for greatest efficiency (rather than dictated by a roof slope) and on a turntable tracked to follow the Sun, driven by a low-power motor and gearbox so its loss to the system is very low. The whole apparatus is on the flat roof of an outbuilding, which I think also contains the large float batteries.

Not content with that, he and his wife built a home extension whose flat roof holds a solar water-heating system he also built himself, using ordinary domestic central-heating radiators inside special enclosures. This cannot face the mid-day sun but is still effective, as it heats the mains water in a large, insulated storage tank.

Scotland is not known for a sub-tropical climate, but I gather his installations all work very well. His village has mains electricity but not gas so the residents have to rely on tank-stored gas; and this water system reduces the gas needed for the domestic hot-water.

Scotland is known for wind though, and everywhere you look in my brother's area, the hill-tops sprout wind-turbines, mainly feeding the National grid.
SusanInFlorida · 31-35, F
@NeoNeo I think there should be some sort of long term contract between electric companies and rate payers who install rooftop panels. so those bidirection payments don't get suspended or radically changed on a whim.

many people installing rooftop solar have 10 financing on those panels, and need to cover the monthly payments.
GerOttman · 70-79, M
You know that's what they said about atomic power. electricity would be so cheap they wouldn't even meter it!

Good times, good times...
SusanInFlorida · 31-35, F
@GerOttman upvoted. my dad said this
NeoNeo · 46-50, M
Bidirectional meter for solar panel is the solution. Electricity generated by panels goes to the grid and house gets usual electricity from grid as usual. This system doesn't require battery or any kind of power storage.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@NeoNeo Well, yes, that is the basic system... when the sun shines on it. The storage is to cover the times when it is not and everyone needs their lights on.

So without the batteries the national grid still needs some alternative power source.

What do you mean by a "bidirectional meter", though? A meter simple measures something.
Probably sell it to China and India, which use as much coal annually as the entire rest of planet Earth combined.

And who install more solar and wind energy capacity annually than the entire rest of planet Earth combined.
@SusanInFlorida I’m aware it’s non-Chinese, but the article quoted Chinese reports.

Also, in that case, as I asked, please provide me with photos.

And by the way, what are you trying to prove?
SusanInFlorida · 31-35, F
@wildland thanks for confirming my views. China is not releasing info to the western world. local observers are leaking it to western websites.

case closed?
@SusanInFlorida No. Show me these photos.

Also, I'm afraid none of this is going to slow the death of fossil fuels, and the emergence of a world powered by wind and solar.

Sorry.

 
Post Comment