Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

The Right Way to Tariff Chinese Goods.

First, Congress should vote on repealing PNTR (permanent normal trade relations), granted by Congress in 2000.

Once they do that, require a presidential declaration that China meets the conditions for getting MFN (most favored nation status).

From 1980 – 1999, China was granted Most Favored Nation status through presidential proclamation on an annual basis because the Trade Act of 1974 stated that “MFN status may not be conferred on a country with a nonmarket economy if that country maintains restrictive emigration policies” China was, and still is, a nonmarket economy and restricted emigration, but the Act allowed the president to “waive this prohibition on an annual basis if he certified that granting MFN status would promote freedom of emigration in that country.”

Russia lost MFN when it invaded Ukraine. Cuba hasn't had it for six decades.

Isn't it time to put human rights back into U.S. foreign policy with respect to China? Make THAT a moral issue for putting high tariffs back on China, while at the same time encouraging disinvestent by companies to more favorable markets, such as Mexico and the rest of Central and South America (which would have the added benefit of reducing undocumented immigrants coming to the U.S. for jobs).

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
CedricH · M
Russia lost MFN when it invaded Ukraine

And the same ought to be done to PNTR if or when China invades or indefinitely blockades Taiwan.

while at the same time encouraging disinvestent by companies to more favorable markets, such as Mexico and the rest of Central and South America
This is an excellent suggestion even though diversification would be a better term than divestment. This can be facilitated by the US government without harmful tariffs on the Chinese economy - for instance - by entering into FTA negotiations with allied or friendly countries. Re-entering the CPTPP, or negotiating a FTA with Mercosur would be reasonable, efficient and would indirectly pressure the Chinese government to reform and make concessions pertaining to the non-market and distortive features of its economic model.
beckyromero · 36-40, FVIP
@CedricH
And the same ought to be done to PNTR if or when China invades or indefinitely blockades Taiwan.

We differ on this as I wouldn't wait for that invasion to happen. China should be stripped of PNTR because of their other actions.
CedricH · M
@beckyromero Yes, we do disagree on that. I don’t think it would be an advisable step either strategically or economically and I wouldn’t expect any positive human rights impact.