Anxious
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Is Britain heading for (even) tougher times?

The Conservative government has recently announced a 'mini-budget' that gives sweeping tax cuts for corporations and high earners. The stated intention behind it is to increase growth on the supply side by attracting businesses and rewarding innovation:

https://www.politicshome.com/news/article/mini-budget-explained-kwasi-kwarteng-tax-cuts

This is highly unlikely to work and will likely fail even on its own terms. Trickle-down economics has been discredited time and time again whenever it and wherever it has been tried. Given low overall demand levels in the world economy (because many economies have problems) this is less likely to work than ever. Even if growth was created by these cuts then the likelihood would be that higher earners would save money or reinvest in property, further inflating our already very inflated housing market. The markets are not impressed and there has already been a mini-run on the pound as traders bet against the future of the UK economy.

To do this, our government has greatly increased our deficit. In recent history, our Conservatives were all committed deficit hawks and frequently attacked the left for wanting to spend more than the national income. Their latest solution is the worst of both worlds: it increases the national debt, whilst doing nothing to improve Britain's crumbling services and infrastructure. The US Republicans have done similar things in the past and with bad results. However, the damage of these policies was somewhat tempered by America's vast economic resources. When your currency is the world's reserve, then you can get away with a few mistakes.

High earners will do well, at least in the short term. Whereas poor or middle-income people will continue to feel the crush of Britain's major cost of living crisis. This is a bit like a fire engine, driving past a fire to drop a bottle of wine off at a house up the street.

I think the policies of Kwateng and Truss will run into big problems and they will try to bail things out with further cuts to our already underfunded services. They are trying to make it harder for unionised workers to go on strike, which reveals the raw class nature of their policies. Strap in.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Abstraction · 61-69, M
'Trickle-down economics is code for trickle-up economics,' (John Clarke).

Similar in Australia where our new Labor government are still pushing through the tax cuts for the wealthy that the conservatives had talked about because they said they included it in the election promises. I assure you, nobody who voted for them was thinking about this and wants them to pour billions of dollars into the hands of the wealthy. I'm not sure anyone was aware they had made it a 'promise'. But they have to pay the piper. We can only have decent government when minorities not beholden to big interests hold the balance of power. Almost happened here - missed it by one member.

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/sep/23/liz-truss-power-extreme-neoliberal-thinktanks
So... the thinktanks for the wealthy have decided on tax cuts at the moment it appears.
Burnley123 · 41-45, M
@Abstraction
But they have to pay the piper.

That is the thing. The ruling class is the one voting block that you can't break promises on. Sigh.
Abstraction · 61-69, M
@Burnley123 There is a shift in Australia to break up the major parties and use our preferential voting system to do it. People haven't realised it costs nothing to vote for a special interest party because your preferenced major party will get your vote if they fail. It's only just starting to catch on.
Many who normally voted right-wing liberal voted 'teal' independents who stood for climate change action, against corruption, against misogyny, etc. If their independent didn't get in their preference would go to liberal.
Similar with Labor. Many voted green or independent first. Unfortunately this wasn't quite as strong and Labor got the majority.
The best government we've had in 20-30 years was about a decade ago when several independents held balance of power and big party had to negotiate policy.
whowasthatmaskedman · 70-79, M
@Abstraction Do not take anything as gospel until the October budget... Labor has the almost perfect excuse to pull those cuts IF they can show a reason why to the people...Sure it was a promise.. But it was not policy for labor in the first place..And they just have to cry "New direction" and enough people will follow..😷
Abstraction · 61-69, M
@whowasthatmaskedman I heard from my local member just today who is Labor and her reply suggests they will review these cuts and make a decision. Not a fan of the potential of watering down ICAC also. I'm hoping for good things from this government but watching closely.
whowasthatmaskedman · 70-79, M
@Abstraction I feel similar. But like a certain other nation with a certain other replaced leader, I think just getting rid of the old is itself a good first step. And it does concern me any time the guy in charge is more concerned about the next life than how people are going to fare in this one. Believe me I am playing nice about our right at this point. I am sure Labor will get things wrong. But not so much or so deliberately..😷