Anxious
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Is Britain heading for (even) tougher times?

The Conservative government has recently announced a 'mini-budget' that gives sweeping tax cuts for corporations and high earners. The stated intention behind it is to increase growth on the supply side by attracting businesses and rewarding innovation:

https://www.politicshome.com/news/article/mini-budget-explained-kwasi-kwarteng-tax-cuts

This is highly unlikely to work and will likely fail even on its own terms. Trickle-down economics has been discredited time and time again whenever it and wherever it has been tried. Given low overall demand levels in the world economy (because many economies have problems) this is less likely to work than ever. Even if growth was created by these cuts then the likelihood would be that higher earners would save money or reinvest in property, further inflating our already very inflated housing market. The markets are not impressed and there has already been a mini-run on the pound as traders bet against the future of the UK economy.

To do this, our government has greatly increased our deficit. In recent history, our Conservatives were all committed deficit hawks and frequently attacked the left for wanting to spend more than the national income. Their latest solution is the worst of both worlds: it increases the national debt, whilst doing nothing to improve Britain's crumbling services and infrastructure. The US Republicans have done similar things in the past and with bad results. However, the damage of these policies was somewhat tempered by America's vast economic resources. When your currency is the world's reserve, then you can get away with a few mistakes.

High earners will do well, at least in the short term. Whereas poor or middle-income people will continue to feel the crush of Britain's major cost of living crisis. This is a bit like a fire engine, driving past a fire to drop a bottle of wine off at a house up the street.

I think the policies of Kwateng and Truss will run into big problems and they will try to bail things out with further cuts to our already underfunded services. They are trying to make it harder for unionised workers to go on strike, which reveals the raw class nature of their policies. Strap in.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Northwest · M
Trickle down economics, with a supply/demand twist. How creative. That's because corporations and high-net individuals are capable of snapping their fingers, and making the supply problem disappear. Unless by that, they mean that China will give them preference when precessing their future orders?
Burnley123 · 41-45, M
@Northwest Yes, it's ridiculous

They think that undercutting the EU on corporation and income tax will attract investment. AND presumably enough investment to compensate for the revenue lost in terms of tax intake. All the economic modelling says that this is BS and the markets are already bet against this working.

I'm generally against using the market as the be-all and end-all but this does demonstrate that the Tories have a political agenda outside of and to the right of capitalist pragmatism!

To give you some insight into our recent political history: under Corbyn and even under Ed Miliband, Labour was frequently and heavily attacked for an alleged lack of economic pragmatism though Labour never had spending pledges that were this uncosted or involved borrowing for 'day-to-day' spending. Also, those policies would have brought tangible benefits to a lot more people. The media reaction against Kwateng and Truss has been negative but not nearly as negative as it should be.
Northwest · M
@Burnley123 This is not unlike the GOP agenda, which consists of accusing the Democrats of lacking economic pragmatism, while offering nothing more than "trickle down" in return. The GOP is so lazy, they don't even mention trickle down in their ads, they just say "we have a plan". Huh?