Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why I don't provide sources

As a former progressive, now right wing supporter and amateur political pundit, many times I express my opinion and get asked to provide my "source" on the matter.

Unless I am directly quoting something or someone, I don't bother providing my sources for my opinion.

Let me explain why:

Typically, this sort of challenge is not in good faith and is usually someone's challenge to "prove it" to them. I used to provide sources. I recall many a time carefully going through my links, finding the best ones, then providing them for the challenger. More often than not, one of 3 things would happen:

1. They ignore it completely, move on, or pretend they never saw the links.
2. They reject it out of hand, usually claiming that the source is unreliable and does not meet their standards for consideration.
3. They cherry pick a portion of the article, claim it's wrong, and then dismiss the entire argument due to this one factoid they feel is erroneous.

I've interacted with a few exceptions on this site, and for those I will make an attempt to share my info, but more often than not, my suggestion is for people to do their own research.

It's what I do. If I hear something I am skeptical on, I do my own searches, consult my own sources, and make up my own mind as to its legitimacy.

Thanks for reading.
This post is closed and no longer available for commenting.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
when i ask for a source? [i]i use it to go find out more[/i]. sometimes i find out things that corroborate the poster, sometimes i find cherry picking,
[i]many times i find inaccurate and misleading sources[/i]
[i]i confess there are sources i dismiss out of hand [/i]having been down that particular rabbit hole, and found only rabbit shit.

for some of us the[b] knowing is more important than the winning[/b]
[i]NOT offering sources comes across as dis-ingenuousness.
[/i]
I am really interested in your statement
[quote]As a former progressive, now right wing supporter[/quote]
I am truly interested in your journey would you care to share that? in private if you like
dancingtongue · 80-89, M
[quote]I am truly interested in your journey would you care to share that? in private if you like
[/quote]

I share SatyrService's curiosity. My personal perspective is that the liberal/conservative spectrum tends to be circular rather than linear, so actually -- if you can get past the labeling and demogoguery -- there are more similarities than differences when you get down to basic values. It is just a matter of liberals being more wont to improve what isn't working and the conservatives being more concerned with preserving what does work. But the left wing/right wing polemics never get past the labeling and demogoguery; it is all about painting the opponent as evil rather than addressing the issue at hand.
SumKindaMunster · 51-55, M
@SatyrService @dancingtongue

I'll just say 2 things:

1. I was greatly impacted by witnessing the left, the Democrats, and their supporters act exactly [i]the way they demanded that Trump and his supporters not act[/i] when they inevitably lost the 2016 Presidential election.
2. My politics haven't changed all that much in the last 10 years. Rather, the culture has shifted radically left on certain issues so now I am more conservative based on the changes of the culture du jour, not my own personal political journey.
@SumKindaMunster thanks,, I can understand this.
the "culture wars" have been horrid for the national discourse
I guess i am asking as much
have the [i]values[/i] you had as a progressive changed? things like health care, climate, education, foreign affairs..
thanks
SumKindaMunster · 51-55, M
@SatyrService Some have. I've shifted my opinion on gun control.

What really changed was my belief that TPTB actually care and intend to do something productive about climate change, health care, education, crime, etc.

They won't. Just pay lip service, point the finger, throw some money at it, and pretend its fixed.
This post is closed and no longer available for commenting.