Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why I don't provide sources

As a former progressive, now right wing supporter and amateur political pundit, many times I express my opinion and get asked to provide my "source" on the matter.

Unless I am directly quoting something or someone, I don't bother providing my sources for my opinion.

Let me explain why:

Typically, this sort of challenge is not in good faith and is usually someone's challenge to "prove it" to them. I used to provide sources. I recall many a time carefully going through my links, finding the best ones, then providing them for the challenger. More often than not, one of 3 things would happen:

1. They ignore it completely, move on, or pretend they never saw the links.
2. They reject it out of hand, usually claiming that the source is unreliable and does not meet their standards for consideration.
3. They cherry pick a portion of the article, claim it's wrong, and then dismiss the entire argument due to this one factoid they feel is erroneous.

I've interacted with a few exceptions on this site, and for those I will make an attempt to share my info, but more often than not, my suggestion is for people to do their own research.

It's what I do. If I hear something I am skeptical on, I do my own searches, consult my own sources, and make up my own mind as to its legitimacy.

Thanks for reading.
This post is closed and no longer available for commenting.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
dancingtongue · 80-89, M
I understand and appreciate your explanation, and it is a valid position for the reasons you state. OTOH, and I accept that I might be the rare exception, I only ask for a source when they appear to be stating fact rather than opinion. And my reason for even perusing the political discussions is an effort to maintain some sort of balanced framework for my own opinions. I am not out to convert anyone, and don't really expect to be converted although I have learned things from the more civil and constructive discussions that have either corrected misconceptions I had, or at least modified my opinions.
SumKindaMunster · 51-55, M
@dancingtongue Fair enough. And I think if the claim is a data point or a direct quote, that's a reasonable expectation.

As I said at the end, a lot of times I just do my own research, you can google the quote or the data point and it will take you to where that info came from, plus you may find corroborating or refuting information on the info provided.
dancingtongue · 80-89, M
@SumKindaMunster My usual first recourse as well. But sometimes the assertion is so elusive a little help is needed to find where it came from.
This post is closed and no longer available for commenting.