This post may contain Sensitive content.
AdultSensitive
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

I Like To Hear About Others Spanking Experiences

More Prison Spanking
In my previous article I wrote about how inmates of Upstate New York prisons were literally spanked for breaking the rules. I have found some more instances of spanking in prison settings that were well-documented if not little-known.
During the American Civil War, Andersonville Prison in Georgia was notorious for its brutality toward Union prisoners of war, so much so that after the war its commander, Henry Wirz, was hanged for war crimes. Conditions were deplorable, and many desperate men were driven to theft.
The commander had a special punishment reserved for thieves--a public spanking. In his book on Andersonville, historian McKinlay Cantor describes the procedure and points out that those who watched it had a general air of merriment. In fact, everyone was laughing except for the poor guy getting spanked!
The culprit was taken to a clearing and the entire camp was assembled to watch. He had his pants taken down and then he was required to bend way over and grip his ankles. The spanking was applied with a long plank known as a "shake," a paddle-like board that was used primarily for roofing. The administrator of the punishment gripped the board with both hands and delivered up to twenty tremendous whacks to the bare bottom of the prisoner while the entire camp laughed at him. The ordeal was terrible and left the thief unable to sit down for a long time, at least a week according to contemporary accounts. Added to his great pain was the ignominy of having his bare heinie spanked like a naughty boy!
The prospect of the spanking struck fear into the hearts of those who witnessed it, and caused any would-be thieves to think twice before taking things that didn't belong to them!
Okay, fellas--now we're going to spank the girls.
In the notorious Bridewell Prison in London, thieves, pickpockets and prostitutes were confined, many under sentence of a flogging. This was a golden opportunity for some entertainment.
In the 18th and early 19th Centuries the well-to-do found diversion in organizing "Flogging Parties" to visit Bridewell on the day the whores were to be spanked. From the time of Shakespeare, prostitutes were given the expected punishment of a whipping for plying their questionable trade. They were usually flogged on the bare back, but the younger girls were birched on the bottom to make things interesting.
A special whipping bench was placed in the center of a large underground hall. This bench was equipped with stocks at either end. One held the girl's neck and wrists, the other set of stocks clamped her ankles. The ladies and gentlemen of society were ushered in to watch the procedure, and they gathered around the bench at a safe distance so that the prison matrons could do their job accurately. Women were employed to do the whipping of the girls, and sometimes even of the men. The condemned girl was brought in and stretched out along the bench, and her head and feet confined in the stocks. Her skirts were raised up to her shoulders, revealing her bare buttocks. Back then women did not wear drawers or bloomers, but shielded their modesty with heavy petticoats. Rods made of bundled birch twigs, which had been soaked in a mixture of salt and vinegar, were placed in a large basket. There were several birches kept handy, because the spanking was so long and vigorous that several birches were usually broken over the girl's behind. There is an illustration from the novel Nell In Bridewell by W. Reinhard, which shows a girl undergoing such a spanking. Heavy-set prison matrons, seen rolling up their sleeves and selecting a good birch rod, proceed with the punishment. The illustration shows the girl in the process of the spanking, and we can see a pool of blood collecting on the wood floor under the bench. The society people, dressed in their best, watch the spanking with glee. It is said that the screams of these poor girls could be heard all over the prison, as the birches slice into their butts and the vinegar and salt sear into the spank spot. It burns, of course, but it is also a rudimentary antiseptic that prevents infection. When the girls were finally released from prison, chances were they thought twice about continuing their dubious careers as ladies of the night.

[image/video - please log in to see this content]

Prison spanking still continues in the form of caning in Malaysia, Singapore and Saudi Arabia. In the American South, the notorious prison strap has been abolished after investigations brought the practice into he public eye.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
I would like to bring back judicial corporal punishment -- the type you are writing about -- that has little resemblance to the childish punishment.

When I asked my Mom when I would be too old to be spanked she told me that spanking was a childish punishment, and when I quit acting like a child I would be too old for a childish punishment -- a line that has recently become a part of my parental repertoire since my oldest is thirteen ☺


("The Ryatts" syndicated comic strip)



But there is nothing childish about judicial corporal punishment --where the skin is literally flayed off their backs -- it is an adult punishment for adult criminals.

But they have one thing in common -- both work!! We have been so overwhelmed by the permissive parenting nonsense cooked up in left-wing think tanks, that no one thinks spanking is very effective anymore --but they are wrong. I am not going to get into it here, but their studies are fake studies, and the wisdom of the ages is on the mark: https://similarworlds.com/story?fid=2327115&tid=596949&name=I-Am-A-Strict-Mom

Judicial corporal punishment also works. Look at the crime rates of the countries which use it. The reason corporal punishment is more prevalent in the black community is not a sad legacy of slavery (as the politically correct commentators are prone to bring up when things like an NFL player is caught switching his child) --but just something that was learned as part of that tragic experience -- whipping works. Ex-slaves interviewed as part of the Federal Writers' Project from 1936 to 1938 confirmed the effectiveness of corporal punishment, especially to discipline young males.See "Why Judicial Corporal Punishment Is Better Than Incarceration" http://bit.ly/2moc7cV

What makes us think Prison Nation, where we lock up more of our citizens than any other nation, including North Korea, is so gosh darn humane or effective?

Judicial corporal punishment also gives the victims something they don't get by locking up the devil, who has caused them so much pain -- so they can nurture their evil amongst fellow possessed compatriots. The victims need the catharsis of spilling blood -- a true healing vengeance.

Judicial corporal punishment is not cruel compared to our current judicial punishments and it needs to be made less unusual.
BadPam · 61-69, F
Becky, interesting treatise. My Mom gave me my last spanking when i was just shy of twenty! So in her eyes I was not too old. But judicial corporal punishment does regard itself as a deterrent, such as the fear of a Singapore caning--although about a thousand men a year are still caned there (but probably not twice!).
@BadPam: I am going to try and find out --but I bet the recidivism rate is much lower in Singapore. It is certainly much cheaper than housing criminals -- it would a good substitute for misdemeanor offenses and lesser felonies (more effective and save a lot of money) and part and parcel of the punishment for more serious offenses --who need to be housed outside society for a period of time.

On spanking age, I can't actually recall when I got my last spanking (there was brief period when they were rather frequent) -- but it was in my Freshman or Sophomore year of High School But even when I went away to college I know I thought it was still a possibility -- so it had some direct deterrent effect then -- although I can't imagine myself compliantly bending over & dropping my drawers to get whacked by my mother at that age --but the situation never came up so I don't know.
BadPam · 61-69, F
@beckychandler: Several years ago some New Hampshire legislators tried to introduce a bill to legalize public spanking of second-offense vandals, but it was defeated by the State Senate. It seems there were too many ramifications involved with spanking people's bare bottoms in the public square. So that was that.
@BadPam: I think the only problem with judicial corporal punishment (although the ACLU. etc. will argue that it is unconstitutionally "cruel and unusual" -- a legal objection I personally don't think holds water) is the weird squeamishness of postmoderns -- they have no problem with the lethal pain of aborting unborn children -- it is antiseptic, silent and hidden away --but they are horrified by a mother swatting a misbehaving child. As a gesture to that squeamishness the whipping could be done inside a correctional institution (as Singapore does) -- even though I think the embarrassment and deterrent effect of a doing it in public would be better.
BadPam · 61-69, F
@beckychandler: Some of the problems raised by the New Hampshire legislature were, for example, what if the prisoner is a young girl and the spanker is a man? That might smack of sexism, especially if he has to pull down the girl's panties for the punishment. What is the prisoner is black and the spanker is white? That might smack of overt racism and hearken back to the days of "De Massa whip de slave." There were so many "what ifs" that they just decided not to do it.
By the way, your observation of too old to be spanked should keep in mind that in many high schools the girls are still paddled at age 18, or as long as they remain in school. I was paddled at 17, which many people felt was too old, but the practice was on the books and still is, as I say, in many states.