Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Will this help or hurt Trump? History doesn't give much insight.

I've already posted about assassination attempts on presidents. Thanks to the historians at electoral-vote.com, here's the history of assassination attempts on presidential candidates. There's no real pattern and this doesn't tell us a whole lot about what to expect now. My personal view is that this will have no effect on Trump's support. He will see a boost next week from the convention (which is true for every candidate) and the shooting is too close to the convention to make it possible to tell if the increase in support is due to that or the inevitable effect of the convention itself. We'll then see a jump in support for Biden from the Democratic convention.

This is why a week is a long time in politics. 24 hours ago, nobody could have predicted this, and 12 hours ago, nobody knew that the shooter was a registered Republican. One problem with this being so close to the convention is that more information about the shooter - his motivations, his associates, etc. - will come out over the next week, taking attention away from the convention itself.

Abraham Lincoln, 1864: Because of the oppressive summer heat in Washington, Lincoln tended to spend summer nights at the soldiers' home a few miles out of town. During one late-night trip in August of 1864, an unknown assailant shot at the President and hit his stovepipe hat. This incident was not widely publicized at the time, and played no role in the election a couple of months later.

Franklin D. Roosevelt, 1933: In February, a mentally imbalanced Italian immigrant named Giuseppe Zangara took several shots at FDR while he was in Miami. Roosevelt was unhurt, but Mayor Anton Cermak of Chicago was wounded, and ultimately succumbed to his injuries. This did not affect the election because Roosevelt was already president-elect by that time.

Theodore Roosevelt, 1912: During his third-party Bull Moose run, Roosevelt was shot in Milwaukee by barkeeper John Schrank. Schrank did it because he said the ghost of William McKinley told him to. Not surprisingly, he was deemed insane and sent to an institution. As to TR, maybe he got a sympathy bounce and maybe he didn't; they didn't have polls back then. However, he definitely did not win the election.

Harry S. Truman, 1948: During Truman's only presidential campaign, militant Zionists sent a few mail bombs to the White House. This played no role in the campaign, as it was not publicly disclosed until the 1970s.

Robert F. Kennedy, 1968: As every reader presumably knows, Bobby was shot and killed in June, shortly after winning the California primary. Obviously, he did not win that election. Nor did the Democrat who eventually got the Party's nomination, Hubert Humphrey.

Richard Nixon/George Wallace, 1972: A man named Arthur Bremer wanted to assassinate Nixon, but came up short because it was just too hard to make the attempt. So, he switched his focus to third-party racist candidate George Wallace, and managed to wound the then-governor of Alabama, leaving Wallace paralyzed for the rest of his days. Nixon did win that election, but in a landslide, and besides, the fact that he was Bremer's first target was not widely known until after the election.
If you watch any of the coverage of his followers, this HELPS.

It is galvanizing those who believe that God has anointed DJT, those who want violence in politics, AND THOSE UNSURE OF THESE.

His ANGER and defiance, photographed with blood & the American flag all in the frame, will be an iconic image.

I think that this has incredibly hardened the ground which the Lincoln Project & Robert Reich have been trying to soften & till; I don't know how much more good they can do.

It also can be used to make those who point out the truth about Jan 6, the 2025 project, and DJT & his entourage of evil seem like enablers.

The sad thing is that this election is an existential moment for us; the only way we recover from the SCotUS' betrayal is to have a strong Democratically-controlled government.

I would not be surprised to find that this sniper was recruited for this, to give DJT his Reichstag fire, and gave his life in order that this...person might again ascend to power which he doesn't understand.

If this happens, it will be odd to talk with them about how it destroys the US, the planet, everything. Couldn't be a worse time to have an idiot at the helm of the US ship of state.
@SomeMichGuy If it comes out that this was staged, that's the one thing that could kill Trump's campaign. More information about the shooter will come out soon - every social media post he ever made, everything he said to anyone throughout his entire life, and anyone else involved in the shooting.
@LeopoldBloom From your lips...
KunsanVeteran · 61-69, M
Trump is constantly spreading lies, hatred, posting thinly veiled threats of violence against his imagined enemies, distorting, stoking racism, publicly praising murderous foreign dictators, etc.

Why would anyone feel sympathy for him? What he makes go around, came around to him. It was inevitable.
Kenworth4954 · 56-60, M
@KunsanVeteran if you need to believe that to make yourself feel better douche bag🤣🤣
KunsanVeteran · 61-69, M
@Kenworth4954 Awww—cry your eyes out and whine just like tRUMP. Do you wear a dirty diaper like him, too?
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
To clarify, the letter bombs were sent to Truman in 1947, back then well before the campaign season and before he was the nominee. In fact, Truman initially denied interest in running for a second term, and didn't publicly declare his candidacy until 1948. With Strom Thurmond's "Dixiecrat" movement splitting the Democratic vote, it was believed that Truman had no chance of winning. FDR's son James Roosevelt attempted to recruit Eisenhower to replace Truman at the convention with telegrams sent to over a thousand delegates asking them to "draft Eisenhower" (Eisenhower, of course, ran for president in 1952 as a Republican, and won). Truman himself had suggested Eisenhower as a potential nominee before he declared his own candidacy. Truman went on to win reelection in 1948; this is the one with the famous "Dewey beats Truman" newspaper headline.

The letter bombs were sent by the paramilitary Lehi group. Their leader, Nathan Yellin-Mor, later admitted sending letter bombs to British targets, but denied sending any to Truman.
It will allow the republicans to have a great convention with lots of momentum heading into the election season. It makes Biden’s strategy of going after trump look silly so that will be put on the back burner for a few weeks. And the Dems worries about their nominee just ramped up a notch.
@BiasForAction Every candidate gets a convention bounce. It will be impossible to tell if Trump's boost next week will be from this or from the convention. The immediate effect is that this will push calls for Biden to withdraw into the background. If Biden makes it another week, he's probably safe.
@LeopoldBloom I stand by my remarks.
Bumbles · 51-55, M
@BiasForAction The standing O will show people crying for dear leader. It’s going to be pure triumph and coronation.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
Whatever the country, politics and personalities, this shooting only just missed murdering Mr.Trump, and did murder two people in the crowd - which alone makes the "set-up" charge look like something from Qanon or its ilk, and perhaps was..

There is no place for this sort of cowardly violence in politics, and it cannot be excused, let alone justified.
Tastyfrzz · 61-69, M
This will change the optics of his rallys and speeches as no one will be allowed; or want, to sit behind him. He'll look like he's talking to himself. He is not a great orator. Even George W. Bush was better.
@Tastyfrzz Don't be surprised if he holds smaller rallies in interior spaces from now on.
Tastyfrzz · 61-69, M
@LeopoldBloom i hear that jail cells are very safe. Padded cells even better.
Northwest · M
None of these folks were reality TV professionals. Have you taken a look at Jr. and Eric's Twitter feeds? How about the SW feed?
Theyitis · 36-40, M
Trump has surged in the Vegas betting odds since yesterday.
MartinII · 70-79, M
@Theyitis Bookmakers are very bad at politics.
Theyitis · 36-40, M
@MartinII Hope you’re right.
It’s obviously this was a set up. He just couldn’t trust his odds in the end I guess.
MartinII · 70-79, M
It depends what happens next, but at the moment I doubt it will make much difference.
AthrillatheHunt · 51-55, M
Don’t forget the attempt on Reagan .
@AthrillatheHunt That was after he'd been sworn in, so I included that in my list of presidential assassination attempts. This is just listing candidates, although technically Truman wasn't a candidate when the letter bombs were sent.
Bumbles · 51-55, M
Help him, but he was winning anyway.
MrSmooTh · 31-35, M
I'm sure it will be a lot like this.
[media=https://youtu.be/E_jNTdGDezw]
Sadly, help!
@Guardian I don't think it will help other than making people who support him already even more motivated.
This has won him that election
MartinII · 70-79, M
@InOtterWords I doubt that. He was winning anyway, but a lot can happen between now and November.
I seem to recall the attempt on "The Gipper" enhanced his popularity.
LordShadowfire · 46-50, M
It allowed for this amazing and totally not staged photo opportunity:

I think he's hoping it will be a distraction. And so far, it has been.

But I don't think it will last. A lot of us are on Twitter right now making sure nobody forgets.
LordShadowfire · 46-50, M
@Thinkerbell Wow, okay. So you're just going to ignore her numerous contributions and accomplishments and literally say the only reason she got the job is that she's black.

But you're not racist.
@Thinkerbell Harris actually polls better than Biden does against Trump right now.

If you think Harris isn't qualified, you should see J.D. Vance. I wonder if Trump picked him as insurance against some other Republican trying to kill him.
LordShadowfire · 46-50, M
@LeopoldBloom He picked him because he's a member in good standing of the Heritage Foundation. You know, that organization he's never heard of?
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Thinkerbell · 41-45, F
@LeopoldBloom

" I'm not interested in your objection to things Trump has said, his personality, or his career before he was president."

Oh, my mistake... I've heard so much from you about "Trump's a convicted felon, a child rapist, an insurrectionist," etc, I thought you wanted me to comment on his character flaws.

"Can you name three policies he enacted while he was president that you disagreed with?"

Sure.

He rolled back certain restrictions on banks that were originally put in place to prevent another banking crisis.
He made the application process for legal immigration more difficult.
He removed some curbs on auto emissions.

Can you name three things the Biden administration did that you didn't like?
Thinkerbell · 41-45, F
@LeopoldBloom
Operation Warp Speed

It's funny/sad that one of the very few good things Trump did, he doesn't want to take credit for because the Right is so anti-science. Now there's that leaked call he made to RFK, where we hear him pretending to be anti-vax.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
@Roundandroundwego One possibility is that the shooting will help the Democrats by raising the question of why a 20 year old was able to get a military-grade weapon.

 
Post Comment