Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Do you believe another Civil War is an impossibility? What factors or issues could spark American Civil War II?

Like neighbor fighting neighbor? I doubt it. The boundaries are less clear and the red states are either on the federal dole or are suppressing the votes of the big blue cities that support their economies.

Who's going to secede? Texas is the only state who might even have a shot at surviving, and as soon as it exterminated or ghettoized Dallas, Houston and San Antonio, its economy would collapse.

I do think we're in for conflict, but my guess it'll mostly be more economic and political as opposed to military.

The religious\Gilead angle is intriguing, I guess, but Atwood had to invent a fertility problem to make that work even as fiction, and really, what we're seeing is probably the last hurrah for the agrarian/Jeffersonian types.
Nah.. apart from a small group of radicals on both sides. The majority of Americans have proved they can’t be gaslit so easily..
they literally jailing one side whilst giving the other a free pass.
Revolutions start that way.. lolz
llloydfred · 56-60, M
@llloydfred Absolutely another civil war is on the rise. Every thing in the Usa is hand ready for it. Liberlism, Smoke Legal Weed, (Federal Government Scientific Max Strength), Inflation, Republican, Democrat, Socialism, Open Boarder, Gun control, religion and the list goes on. Pressure is building. Another Civil War will have an idea named "Progress".
If we're talking about states organizing into separate armies and fighting each other, no.

If we're talking about mass groups of individuals banning together and attacking fellow americans and government institutions yes.
Theyitis · 36-40, M
I read something a few months ago that made me think a Civil War was a very strong possibility. Yes, it’s coming back to me now. Countries that have insurgencies (the modern equivalent of civil wars) all have two factors in common: 1. A major political party that is built not around an ideology but around an ethnic group. The article identified the Republican Party as fulfilling this requirement as it is increasingly becoming a party that serves the interests of white nationalists. 2.They are countries that are either totalitarian but opening up to democracy or democracies that are sliding back towards totalitarianism.
Nope. Most conservative leaders realize that red areas only control 30% of our GDP. They would be LOST without the high productivity of the blue parts of the nation.

Theyitis · 36-40, M
@ElwoodBlues You’ve got a point, that the red states are unlikely to secede; however, secession is not necessary for a civil war. We may have uncoordinated insurgencies simply over election results or perceived government overreach that might amount to civil war.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
justanothername · 51-55, M
War in any form doesn’t benefit anyone. There are never any winners. Only narcissistic dictators with personal agendas.
Open discussion solves more problems than violence ever did.
scrood · 31-35
Though who say it's impossible are the type to run from the trenches and leave you on your own
This civil war, may literally be civil, possibly even cyber 😳
Obviously this is war
HoraceGreenley · 56-60, M

 
Post Comment