Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why is good weather not blamed on Global Warming?

It has been Beautiful in the desert southwest lately.

It seems that only bad weather events are blamed on global warming. But what about good weather?

How can GW only be responsible for the weather that we don't like?
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
SunshineGirl · 36-40, F
Parts of south-east England currently have a climate similar to the Champagne region in the 1970s (when some of the finest vintages were produced) and millions are being invested in vineyards. That is a benign or even positive effect of global warming. But I'm not sure that mitigates the unbearably hot summers in parts of the mediteranean or destruction of property by wildfire.
whowasthatmaskedman · 70-79, M
@SunshineGirl It looks like southern Oz is heading for another drought year. Farmers are missing the autmn rains and victoria is activating its desalination plant to keep the cities drinking water in good supply..😷
DogMan · 61-69, M
@SunshineGirl There have been hot summers in the Mediterranean off and on for thousands of years.

Wildfires are also a natural occurrence, that have happened since the beginning of time. But I agree, made
are Man Made now, because of arson. Most of the California fires were started intentionally. Some were electrical.
And some were started by lightning. Many trees are dead because of the Bark beetle, which makes them tinder.

And on top of it all, the forests are not managed well. States like Utah clean up the forests and make fire breaks.
They do have fires from Lightning strikes, but they do not get out of control.
DogMan · 61-69, M
@whowasthatmaskedman Your country has been through droughts since the beginning of time

It has been said that the 1800's were the worst in 400 years. Apparently 400 years ago it was much worse.
Why was it much worse? What did man do to cause the extreme drought period 400 years ago?

Droughts in the 19th century

Golden Summer, Eaglemont, painted in 1889 by Heidelberg School artist Arthur Streeton, shows the semi-rural Melbourne suburb of Heidelberg during an El Niño drought.
1803 Drought in New South Wales (NSW) that produced several crop failures.
1809 Beginning of an unusually severe drought in NSW that continued until 1811.
1813–1815 Severe drought in NSW that prompted searches for new pastures.
1826–1829 Severe drought in NSW that caused Lake George to dry up and the Darling River to cease flowing.[6]
Since 1860, when adequate meteorological recording commenced, the most severe droughts have occurred commonly at intervals of 11 to 14 years. Major droughts that were recorded later in the 19th century include:

1829 Major drought in Western Australia with very little water available.[7]
1835 and 1838 Sydney and NSW receive 25% less rain than usual. Severe drought in Northam and York areas of Western Australia.
1838–39 Droughts in South Australia and Western Australia
1839 Severe drought in the west and north of Spencer Gulf, South Australia.
1846 Severe drought converted the interior and far north of South Australia into an arid desert.
1849 Sydney received about 27 inches less rain than normal.
1850 Severe drought, with big losses of livestock across inland New South Wales and around the western rivers region.
1864–1866 (and 1868). The little data available indicates that this drought period was rather severe in Victoria, South Australia, New South Wales, Queensland and Western Australia. This drought also helped fires in the Australia outback at the time.
1877 All states affected by severe drought, with disastrous losses in Queensland. In Western Australia many native trees died, swamps dried up and crops failed.
1880 to 1886 Drought in Victoria (northern areas and Gippsland); New South Wales (mainly northern wheat belt, Northern Tablelands and south coast); Queensland (1881–1886, in south-east with breaks – otherwise mainly in coastal areas, the central highlands and central interior in 1883–1886); and South Australia (1884–1886, mainly in agricultural areas).
1888 Extremely dry in Victoria (northern areas and Gippsland); Tasmania (1887–1889 in the south); New South Wales had the driest year since records began; Queensland (1888–89) had a very severe drought, with much native scrub dying and native animals perishing; South Australia had one of its most severe droughts; and Western Australia (central agricultural areas) lost many sheep.[8]
1897 Drought in much of Queensland, compared to 1883–84 droughts
22Michelle · 70-79, T
@SunshineGirl And even some of what is seen as beneficial results may be masking environmental damage that may not be identified for several years.
DogMan · 61-69, M
@22Michelle What kind of environmental damage?
22Michelle · 70-79, T
@DogMan Well since I said it may not be identified I can't identify the specifics. However, it could be the loss of certain species of flora and fauna which can have catastrophic consequences up the food chain.
GeniUs · 56-60, M
@SunshineGirl Bang on. It being warmer in the UK is nice but does not mitigate for all the people affected by floods, droughts and in other countries wildfires, etc. For anybody to say well I'm enjoying it is enormously selfish.
DogMan · 61-69, M
@GeniUs So now we should all feel bad when we have nice weather? Because someone else could be having
bad weather? That is ridicules. I feel happy, not selfish, when we have good weather. Do you feel selfish every
day when you use products made with petroleum, you should. I don't, but you should.
GeniUs · 56-60, M
@DogMan I understand English is not your first language so I'll give you a pass for getting everything wrong there. In future though you should be more careful because you came across as a right prat there.
DogMan · 61-69, M
@GeniUs You wrote this, not me. . For anybody to say well I'm enjoying it is enormously selfish
GeniUs · 56-60, M
@DogMan Take one sentence out of context that makes it work for you but it loses it's context. So yeah be obtuse.