if you had to pick

As drummer Buddy Rich put it in a TV interview with Goodman in the 1970s, “I played with Artie Shaw but [u]you[/u] were the one I [u]wanted[/u] to play with. Artie had a great sound, but it was just [u]one[/u] sound. You had several different sounds.”
In case you’re wondering, Benny’s reply was honest but typical: “I thought you were too loud and played too much drums. You weren’t a good fit for me.”

Benny. I used to want to be just like him.
I played clarinet in school band.

Speaking through a modern lens, I'd probably say Goodman for his commitment to the musician more than the color of the musician. Shaw was also on the same page but didn't have as much impact. And "Sing Sing Sing" is one of my favorites from the era.

Really tough question. I cant pick. My dad and i have discussed this since i was young. We both agree Benny's tone is darker and more dolce. Artie has a more vibrant tone that pierces through the soul.
I cant pick 😅

Artie was not only a fantastic musician, he was also a great author of fiction and non-fiction.

Goodman! Because it’s Benny.

I grew up with Benny Goodman playing in my childhood home. He'd be the one.

Goodman. I’m a fan of Charlie Christian.

Goodman. He swings with the best of them.

Glen Miller

Duke Ellington