Movie or Album The Wall

The movie was nonsensical tripe, but the one thing it has over the album is the closest thing to an official version of "What Shall We Do Now?" which was cut out at the last minute due to there not being enough space for it on the record. It was so last-minute, its lyrics were featured on the original LP booklet. It blows my mind that it's never been released to this day, when it's been performed live by the band and Roger Waters whenever The Wall has been performed in its entirety. Not even during the Why Pink Floyd...? campaign release of The Wall, which featured a slew of never-before released demos, but still not "What Shall We Do Now?"

Very clever....I imagine you too remember their first album....See Emily Play.

Heres the other. To me Waters has more emotion in his vocals here then the album. More feeling and i love it. The only thing wrong is Gilmours solo . Its not long enogh.

[media=https://youtu.be/FZyE4bIylZ4?si=c7BOq8sNXEaxtPOF]

Here's another off the movie that I like better. It just hits different

[media=https://youtu.be/yX4O3dNTFYw?si=b1f7psNxLy4SI0K5]

This is pretty cool even if it was a few years back. Nick seems to get alone with anyone

[media=https://youtu.be/DawCpKEJFUM?si=UbN2zm84gb2V09xi]

Some of the mixes and edits are bizarre. I think even In The Flesh(sung by Geldof) has a weird, jarring edit in the opening riff in the film. I know that people have issues with it, but damned if I didn't understand the entire narrative better after seeing it. PLUS I am a huge Alan Parker fan.