Have you seen American Horror Story?

I am a fan and have been since it first aired. I haven't seen all the seasons. Didn't see 2.

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

Asylum? It's the best and most well developed season of them all. Coven and Asylum are the best seasons of the whole series.

If you were going to skio a season it should have been Freakshow.

Spoiledbrat · F

Cult is my absolute favorite. But I liked Hotel too. @MethDozer

MethDozer · M

@Spoiledbrat Personally I think Freakshow, Hotel, and Cult areball kinda stupid.

Freakshow should gave been good. Had all the right tools but they fucked it right up and made it come off as they had idea what story they had in mind or where to go with it. Hotel was similar. Great characters. The vice demon was great. But they kust theww him in there for no reason and nevwr really explained him or used developed him well. It was great imagry wise but just convoluted and undeveloped nonsense with no real story. Cult was just a dumb as fuck idea to begin with. It was actually amazing how well they developed such a stupid ass "horror " premise . The whole season was just a nonfitting virtue signal. Yet if they worked as hard actually writing and developing a story as they did on that stupid ass idea as they did on the settings of potential that was Freakshow or hotel those seasons could have been great.

Ryan Murphy isnt really good at writing or storymaking. He's good at shiw ideas but kinda sucks at actually writing them.

Spoiledbrat · F

Cult was badass. It was absolutely brilliant. @MethDozer

BeautifulLibra · 46-50, F

@MethDozer I liked Freakshow, cult, ok the list is:

Murder House-ok
Asylum-didn't care for
Coven-ok
Freak Show-ok
Hotel-ok
Roanoke-never watched
Cult-ok
Apocalypse-I liked that one and need to re watch it.
1984- enjoyed that one too
Season 10 was a double feature

This comment is hidden. Show Comment

MethDozer · M

@BeautifulLibra How can you say freakshow was bettwr rhan asylum? Asylum actually made sense and had a cohesive plot.

Roanoake is okay but not great. It kinda goes downhill a bit when it moves to the present day.

BeautifulLibra · 46-50, F

@MethDozer Which one was it when these men all dressed in white rushed in someone home and took a boy away because of his DNA. He submitted his DNA through an ancestry website?

MethDozer · M

@BeautifulLibra I honestly gave up on tje show vecause of Freakshow being so bad. Then my sis made me Watch Apocolypes wich was pretty good so I went back and watched hotel AND cult amd wasnt happy about it.

Spoiledbrat · F

That one I didn't watch all tne way through. I couldn't get into it. @BeautifulLibra

MethDozer · M

@BeautifulLibra In your description you said you didnt watch Asylum.