Should I use the same nail polish color to match my fingers and toes ?

i say...do what you want! at vbs one of the 6 year olds in my group had a different color on each fingernail and i thought that looks like summer.

I normally use tangerine for my toes.

Have you got 20 colours? 😬

If the toe nails will be visible often I'd probably paint them the same.
Typically I have French manicure for my finger nails, and my toe nails are a vibrant red.

I generally use the same for both. But just now I have bright red fingernails and Nightshade black toenails.

I rarely match.
For some reason, I like certain colors on my toes that I don't like on my fingers, and vice versa.

I would say match, but I am not an expert on it.

Only if I can paint your toes purple!

Always, ever the same...

A single color.

Consistency 😌

Match

Match!

Match!

Match

Of course! Unless you coordinate them in some other way.