Like just your name and number or did you write some other message as well? To indicate your interest beyond customer service perhaps. I’m curious if she ends up reaching out lol.

"I am holding your pen for ransom, if you ever want to see your pen again meet me at Joe's diner at 6pm on Thursday night"
"I will wait for 1 hour and if you don't turn up, it's CURTAINS for Mr.Pen"
"signed; your new friend"

You failed to leave a good impression by taking her pen. I know to you it sounds trivial, but taking anything is a bad sign.

Smooth

smooth

Show us a picture of yourself, and I will let you know if she will call.

If stealing her pen twice gets you her phone number, I fear for the country.

Did she bite?

Let us see how your pen romance goes 🤪

How many cars have you bought