This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
BizSuitStacy · M
Biologically, XX is female, XY is male, but there are variants. For example, how do you classify XXY...aka hermaphrodite or intersex...someone who is born with both genitalia? There are other genetic variants as well.
Pyschologically, fugeddaboutit! Let's not go there.
Pyschologically, fugeddaboutit! Let's not go there.
Sicarium · 46-50, M
@BizSuitStacy That's easy, a genetic abnormality of the two genders. Extreme examples and exceptions do not define the norm.
BizSuitStacy · M
@Sicarium agreed, it's not the norm. But the question is "how many," not "what is normal."
Sicarium · 46-50, M
@BizSuitStacy Neither is the question. First you establish if there is a baseline, a norm. Which there is, XX and YY. That's the evolutionary answer to procreation. Now you can document exceptions or extreme examples. But it's not a matter of how many there are. It's a matter of if that fits the baseline or not.
BizSuitStacy · M
@Sicarium that's a definition of the normal boundaries. We both agree, XXY falls outside the normal range. But what gender is assigned to an XXY? I wasn't able to answer that question 30+ years ago when I took genetics. Typically, an XXY ends up choosing. So maybe the answer really is just 2.

SW-User
@BizSuitStacy there is only two, xxy is a mutation. a genetic outlier from the normal xx xy genetic code.
BizSuitStacy · M
@SW-User all you are saying is that an XXY falls outside the normal spectrum...to which I've said, I agree it falls outside the normal spectrum. But, just because it's unusual, doesn't mean it gets excluded from the "how many genders" discussion.

SW-User
@BizSuitStacy its not a real gender. its a mutation.