Random
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Texas makes Bible passages required reading for millions of public school students

The Guardian reports:

“Critics say mandating Bible reading for over 5m students breaches constitutional separation of church and state”

By Marina Dunbar

“The Texas education board has approved a broad new statewide reading list that, for the first time, will make passages from the Bible required reading for more than 5 million public school students.

Under the new initiative, Bible stories will become mandatory reading for millions of public school students in addition to a more standard collection of books, renewing debate over growing efforts in the US to increase the role of religion in classrooms.

The rollout will be staggered, starting with elementary school students in 2030.

The Republican-controlled Texas state board of education gave final approval to the plan during a vote on Friday. Last year, Texas became the largest state to require the Ten Commandments to be displayed in every classroom.

The move stems from a 2023 Texas law requiring state education officials to designate at least one literary work for every grade level, with the state board expanding on that mandate by recommending multiple texts for each grade. While teachers may still assign books outside the list, they must do so in addition to the required selections.

The reading list states that excerpts from the Book of Jonah and the Book of Psalms will be required reading beginning in seventh grade. Additional excerpts from several parts of the Bible, such as the Book of Lamentations and the Book of Genesis, will become part of the curriculum for high school students.

The list has sparked strong criticism. Opponents say it breaches the constitutional separation of church and state, lacks diversity and gives preference to Christianity over other faiths. Supporters argue that Judeo-Christian traditions played a central role in the country’s founding and should be represented in public school teachings.

The curriculum has drawn criticism not only for its inclusion of religious texts but also for its heavy emphasis on older works, many written by white male authors, in a state where more than half of public school students are Hispanic or Black.

Last year, Donald Trump pledged to “protect prayer” in public schools. During his first term, he introduced measures that aimed to make it easier for religious organizations to access federal programs. Texas, a Republican-led state that educates roughly one in 10 public school students in the US, has often influenced education policy nationwide.”

My comments:

A clear violation of the Constitutional separation of church from state.
Top | New | Old
peterlee · M
Do you not reflect in America?

Meditation is an important aspect of life.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@peterlee What's reported seems to be against any thinking.
JSul3 · 70-79
This takes effect in 2030.
We have four years to fight this!

The public schools are not churches!
Texas is just gonna become a theocracy—
Constitution be damned. 🤨
Crazywaterspring · 61-69, M
@bijouxbroussard Thirty years of Republican governance has done that. Now they're writing Gov Ann Richards out of textbooks.
BohoBabe · M
I do agree that Christianity played a role in the founding of Western Civilization, and the Bible should be taught as literature.

What I don't like is that they're not going to teach it as literature, they're going to teach it as being the one true religion. And they're banning books that contradict their theocratic worldview.
BohoBabe · M
@Khenpal1 I love being perverted.
SatanBurger · 36-40, F
@BohoBabe At the same time, a lot of the cultures that were wiped out were beginning their own cultural revolutions. If they had not been wiped out, we likely would have had western civilization anyways but in a different form maybe. So I disagree that the Bible was part of any western civilization.

Before Christianization swept through Europe (and later the Americas), Celtic, Germanic, Slavic, and various indigenous societies had complex legal codes, sophisticated agricultural practices, vibrant oral traditions, and distinct spiritual frameworks.

If those cultures hadn't been systematically absorbed or wiped out, a complex, advanced civilization absolutely would have emerged on the European continent. It wouldn't have been a "void" necessarily.
SatanBurger · 36-40, F
@BohoBabe Also the Aztecs aren't western (well they didn't call themselves Aztecs it was colonists) but right before they were toppled there was already a larger majority who wanted to go away from sacrifice and other things. So they were starting to evolve too. They likely would be a power country if they had not been wiped out. So there's lots of ways that our civilization would be our civilization anyways.
peterlee · M
More disturbing is that Texas is making Dickens compulsory reading. That will bore you to tears. There are other English authors that could be read such as Hardy, Thackeray, or Elliot. Why not go for something more modern such as Murdoch or McEwen.

Perhaps a couple of modern Japanese authors in translation, such as Mieko Kawakami or Yoko Ogawa. Now they would broaden your mind.
@peterlee If you haven’t figured it out yet here is a hint:

This has absolutely nothing to do with “broadening the minds of students”

This has everything to do with indoctrinating students in one (and only one) particular interpretation of acceptable religion
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@KunsanVeteran I'm baffled too why the arcane committe responsible should bar Charles Dickens, given that the social crusading in some of his novels could well be thought very much in the best spirit of Christianity.

However, Dickens didn't proselytise even though Christianity in its several main denominations were much stronger in Britain his day than now. Maybe that he didn't, is the problem with the school authorities!

Arguably about the only of the best-known Dickens novels that might be regarded as somehow religious is A Christmas Carol*, and its message of redemption and eventual kindliness is wholly and rather sentimentally positive.


What he did highlight by a sort of dark caricture was the very limited curriculum compounded by low teaching ability matched by high physical and mental cruelty, he evidently observed as allowed in English schools in the mid-19C. His fictitious ones were very small, struggling boarding-schools run by total ignorami; but even the most prestigious of the contemporary, real public schools (by UK definition) were little better.

(As in David Copperfield, also a tale of domestic child-abuse and what in UK Law is the modern offence of "coercive and controlling behaviour", against David's mother; and Nicholas Nickleby; the eponymous hero being what we'd now call a 'teaching assistant'.)

The illiterate brute who ran the school in the latter book was apparently based on a real one who beat one child so savagely that he blinded him. The boy's parents successfully sued, and with his career over the school-teacher / proprietor emigrated.


Or is the Texans' problem with Dickens elsewhere, such as his championing of the poor? Oliver Twist is a very strong condemnation of the workhouse system, for example; while others of his works unearth the grimmer side of 19C London life.

Some might criticise the Oliver Twist narrative for helping encourage unpleasant stereotypes of the Jews, but I don't. Shakespeare's Shylock, The Merchant of Venice, was much closer to doing that, perhaps because the usurer's culture is a central point in a story whose characters are all well-off. Anti-Semitism was prevalent but I think Dickens was examining the grinding poverty that drove Fagin into becoming a thief grooming boys into the same crime, rather than his parentage. The musical Oliver! with its idiotic Gotta Pick a Pocket Or Two, is a travesty, making the urchins and their Svengali into a laughing-stock. Even so, might this be another point against allowing delicate school-children to read the novel?

'''''

*Incidentally that is not Dicken's only ghost story. He also a short story set very much in his own time with the haunting involving the very latest railways "technology": The Signalman.
peterlee · M
@KunsanVeteran So perhaps you should go for Oscar Wilde. His treatment epitomises British hypocrisy.

Still around in Thatcherite Britain.
Elessar · 31-35, M
50 years from now you'll see memes like this


Except about the USA
“Texas unleashes sleeping giant as conservatives face reckoning over 'truth'”

AlterNet reports:

By Brett Wilkins

“As education officials in Texas ban hundreds of books that run afoul of their interpretation of Christian morality, the State Board of Education on Friday approved a required reading list that forces the state’s more than 5 million public school students to read from the Bible.

The Republican-controlled SBOE voted 9-5 with one abstention to approve the list, which includes passages from the Book of Exodus as well as the Shepherd’s Psalm and the myths of Adam and Eve and David and Goliath.

“We’re going to stop watering down American history. We’re going to teach the truth. Our nation was founded as a Christian nation, and Texas is a Christian state,” Republican board member Brandon Hall—who is also a youth pastor at Cavalry Baptist Church in Springtown—said during a Thursday press conference in Austin.

That “truth” omits or marginalizes climate change, US imperialism, women’s history, the genocide of Indigenous peoples, slavery, and racism.

Evelyn Brooks, the only Republican SBOE member to vote against the required reading list, told CNN on Friday that she believes the board’s move is “unconstitutional.”

“Teachers need to have their autonomy,” she said. “They’ve been selecting books for decades.”

In 2023, Texas’ Republican-controlled Legislature passed HB 1605, which mandated the creation of a K-12 required reading list and directed the Texas Education Agency to develop state-owned textbooks. Those texts, called Bluebonnet Learning, contain lessons on Christianity starting in kindergarten. The SBOE approved Bluebonnet Learning as an optional curriculum in late 2024 and is currently working to correct thousands of errors in the curriculum at a cost of over $8 million to Texas taxpayers.

The SBOE action comes amid a legal battle over SB 10, a law signed last year by Republican Texas Gov. Greg Abbott that requires public elementary and secondary schools to display the Ten Commandments in every classroom. US District Judge Fred Biery, an appointee of former President Bill Clinton, subsequently issued a preliminary injunction blocking the law. Texas families also sued to block the legislation. However, Republican Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton—who is running for US Senate—demanded that schools comply with the law.

Public schools “exist to educate students with diverse faith backgrounds, as well as those who adhere to no faith doctrine,” the Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF) said Friday. “Public schools are not Sunday schools, and elected officials have no business using state power to elevate one religion above all others. A required reading list that overwhelmingly favors Christian texts while excluding the writings and literary traditions of other faiths, not to mention the perspectives of millions of nonreligious Americans, sends an unmistakable message about who belongs and who does not.”

FFRF co-president Annie Laurie Gaylor asserted that “a mandatory public school reading list should never function as a Bible lesson.”

“Texas is telling millions of children that one religion deserves the government’s seal of approval, while everyone else is an afterthought,” she added. “That’s government-sponsored religious favoritism—and the First Amendment strictly forbids it.”

Rabbi Joshua Fixler at Congregation Emanu El in Houston told CNN Friday that “this list is full of Christian texts that are inappropriate for public school classrooms.”

“As a rabbi and a parent of Jewish kids, I think it is vital that this board make a distinction between teaching about religion and teaching religion,” he added. “This list will force teachers to cross that line.”

Fort Worth high school teacher Chanea Bond told The Associated Press on Friday that the SBOE’s required reading list is “very old and very white.”

“It is very narrow and does not represent what classrooms in Texas look like,” she said. “Going through most of high school without ever having much value put into voices that sound like yours kind of sends a message that your voices aren’t valuable.””
SatanBurger · 36-40, F
@KunsanVeteran I love how they say they are not gonna water down history but actively ignore slavery
@SatanBurger They’re not watering down history!

They are attempting to abolish the true history and replace it with their lies, omissions, and bigoted bias.
Fukfacewillie · 56-60, M
Fuck Texas.
@Fukfacewillie Abbott and Paxton are doing just that!
Wrong…so very wrong.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
@peterlee Your point—if you have one—is obscure.
ArishMell · 70-79, M
@Crazywaterspring I know, but I'm puzzled why that State's authorities are taking this course.
@peterlee You’re not a United States lawmaker, and therefore not obligated to regard or respect our country’s Constitution.

Unfortunately, part of becoming a member of the U.S. government is a commitment to upholding that Constitution—yet based on results it’s meaning less and less to leaders of our "red" states (like Texas and Florida, etc.) too. 😞

 
Post Comment