English question

Both (1) and (2) can be used with the implication that he is still alive:

(1) He is dying.
(2) He is not dying.

In that instance, I'd like to know what the difference in nuance is between them.

I'm a researcher of English linguistics.

This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

Hidenori · 46-50, M

Thanks, everyone. I posted this question on a Facebook group and I got very insightful feedback from native speakers:

Ans. (K.M UK English)
(1) He is still alive, but not for much longer.
(2) He is alive, and will remain alive indefinitely.

Ans. (B.K US English)
(1) He is dying= To the best of my knowledge, he is in the process of dying, and will likely die soon, but he has not died yet.
(2) He is not dying = He is not in the process of dying because either:
(a) He has not begun it. = He's fine, or at least not in imminent danger.
or
(b) He has already completed it. = He's dead.