This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »

SW-User
Yes, and the vast majority of cats has a tail, but only a tiny percentage of animals with a tail are cats. Having a tail says as little about being a cat as being a Muslim says about being a terrorist, regardless of the obvious 1-way link.
stewf · 31-35, M
@SW-User I think you din't read it properly.

SW-User
@stewf I think I did. You're saying that most terrorists are Muslims. I explained how that only says something about terrorists and nothing about Muslims.
stewf · 31-35, M
well, could you stat some recent terrorist acts and what they claimed when they committed?

SW-User
@stewf why should I? We already agree that most terrorists claim to be Muslim.

SW-User
@SW-User very well presented argument