Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Christopher Columbus' true motivations

Everyone already knows that Christopher Columbus was a genocidal maniac, so there's no point in going into detail. What many people don't know is that he was under strict orders from King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella to not "bother or upset" the Native Americans, and certainly not to enslave them and force them to mine gold for Columbus to steal. There was a prohibition at that time against enslaving Christians, and the goal was to convert the Natives to Christianity, so oppressing them would have been counterproductive.

What's lesser known is the real purpose of Columbus' voyage. It was not, as commonly thought, merely to find a faster route to China for the space trade. Following the Ottoman's capture of Constantinople in 1453, the Silk Road was closed to Europeans. On top of that, the Mamluks had controlled Jerusalem since defeating the Mongols in 1260, and would not be ousted by the Ottomans until 1516. Marco Polo had described the Great Khan as amenable to Christianity. There was also an old legend of Prester John, a Christian king in the far east. Columbus' dream was to convert the Great Khan to Christianity, find Prester John, and convince them to join the Europeans on a crusade to liberate the Holy Land. His explorations were primarily motivated by religion, although he did negotiate one-tenth of any proceeds from spice or gold for himself. Columbus was eventually recalled to Spain when reports of his brutality toward the Natives reached the crown.

Although the Italian peninsula was known by that name, Columbus wouldn't have thought of himself as "Italian" as the country of Italy did not exist at that time. He was from Genoa and would have considered himself Genoese. His native language was not Italian, but Ligurian, which had significant influence from French.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
Northwest · M
Isabella and Ferdinand, approved Columbus's journey, to locate a direct, maritime spice route to India. They, Columbus included, did not realize there was a continent along the way.

When he failed to find spices, Columbus tried to salvage the journey, by taking captives and gold back, and promising a steady supply of both.

Isabella wanted to turn them Christian, something Columbus promised he would do, and Ferdinand wanted the gold, something Columbus promised. And yes, he was a Ligurian speaking Genovese. The concept of modern states had not developed at the time.

But Columbus day is what Columbus day is, and Italians may consider it an insult if you associate it with slavery, and rape natural resources.
@Northwest Columbus' first mistake was to confuse the shorter Roman mile with the modern mile, considerably underestimating the distance. Eratosthenes had calculated the earth's circumference to remarkable accuracy thousands of years earlier. Several of the advisors to the monarchs Columbus approached first before going to Ferdinand and Isabella told him that China was much too far to reach by ocean, even without knowing that there was a continent in the way.

You are correct about the spice trade, but from Columbus' own writings, it was clear that his main goal was to enlist the Great Khan and Prester John in a Crusade to free the Holy Land from the Mamluks.

I get how Italian-Americans view Columbus Day as an honor; there was a Sopranos episode about this. It makes no sense that Italians get a federal holiday when Germans don't. There are far more Americans of German descent than Italian. We can keep Columbus Day if they want, but it shouldn't be a federal holiday; it should be like St. Patrick's Day or Cinco de Mayo that commemorate those ethnic groups but aren't official holidays.
Northwest · M
@LeopoldBloom He had a letter from Ferdinand and Isabella, who were seeking to establish a direct relationship with Cathay (China) and the Great Khan. He was convinced, when he reached Cuba, that he was at what Marco Polo described as Quinsay (Hangchow), and dispatched a team to deliver the Royal letter to the Great Khan. There are the facts, but it's hard to second-guess what each person was thinking.

I don't think Columbus Day should be a national holiday, but it seemed like to should, when I was growing up in the San Francisco area. But it should be the same as St Patrick's day.
@Northwest Ferdinand and Isabella were interested in another spice route. The Crusade angle was just Columbus.