Do you think it is ok to give advice on SW when people ask questions?

Sometimes people say thanks and it was good advice and sometimes people say who do you think you are giving advice? I mean no offence but surely if people ask questions then the point of SW is to give your opinion and it can be discarded or taken on board? I just wonder if maybe you re not really meant to say anything serious here?

Top | Newest First | Oldest First

SW-User

I think if people ask the question then get butt hurt if you answer that's on them. Answer the way you see fit and if they don't like it oh well :)

mljenkins · 51-55, F

I agree, if you don't want answers, like them or not, don't ask questions!!!!!

SW-User

Yes
give your advice
they can take or leave it

sogdianrock · 61-69, M

hi NeitherLostNorFound
thanks. My viewpoint also.
here a recent example where I touched a nerve!
"A pile of phychobabble used as a dam to hide a pile of stinking dog crap doesn't deserve much more than to be dismissed, if you can really prove the dog crap came from actual guard dogs. "
Not sure I even understood to or where the negative energy was coming from. Do not want to dismiss a genuine point from which I should learn and change though.
Best wishes
:)

celine211 · 22-25, F

There's no rule that I know of that says that..if a person asked a question I assume he/she wants an answer if the person doesn't want any serious advise or vica versa should warn in the question.
Usual they get angry i think because they don't like the answer they're given for some reason

Miram · 31-35, F

I appreciate constructive criticism, thoughtful advice and input based on information, even if I don't reply to it.

There are times when I just want to vent but I make that clear beforehand

sogdianrock · 61-69, M

hi Darkcosmos
Yes me also. I do not give advice where it is not sought or even consider it advice really - just observation and opinion.
Best wishes
:)

bowman81 · M

I answer, they are free to take it as they like. Sometimes with humor, sometimes serious. Remember most advice is worth about what you paid for it. I TRY to not take myself too seriously.

softspokenman · M

Yes, they opened the door, invited you in, and you just walked in.

goagainsttheflow · 26-30, F

It's why I walk on eggshells when it comes to advice. Silly, I know.

sogdianrock · 61-69, M

hi goagainsttheflow
I am old enough to not to care so much maybe. I also think if I have something I think I can contribute to a genuine question then why not offer it?
Best wishes
:)

Add a comment...