Top | Newest First | Oldest First
CopperCicada · M
I think he was beyond good. One of the greatest in American history. I would say there were more exceptional corps commanders. Stonewall Jackson. Nathan Bedford Forrest. Grant himself described Forrest as the greatest military strategist the Civil War produced on either side— north or south. The one thing Lee lacked was the long game strategy.
SW-User
Well, I mean, he lost soooooo....
View 3 more replies »
SW-User
@Mattypppants says the grown man in a diaper. I can't even bro. Go back underground.
Firespirit · 26-30, M
@Mattypppants Life is not all black and white there is no good guys bad guys here just points of view. and as a general goes his planning and strategy is great. and all the life he saved towards the end
Mattypppants · 56-60, M
@SW-User I would not go in your cave
Yes, he was. He was also a traitor who backed a lost cause.
He grew up in the United States. @Firespirit
Firespirit · 26-30, M
@Texasgurl His state where he grew up
Which was part of the US@Firespirit
Mattypppants · 56-60, M
No they lost war
Mattypppants · 56-60, M
@Snuffy1957 well losers can be good I guess
Snuffy1957 · 61-69, M
@Mattypppants just cuz we ran out of bullets don't make us losers!
Mattypppants · 56-60, M
Why u need bullets lol
xSharp · 31-35, M
"They've got us surrounded again, the poor bastards." - Creighton Abrams
Amylynne · 26-30, F
YES! untill he made that fatal mistake at G'burg, lost the entire war on that day
Snuffy1957 · 61-69, M
He was an excellent General! Respected by the North and the South!
benJohnson99 · 18-21, M
History records yes I guess
SW-User
Yes