“Everyone is different” in what/how and why they do & say things, so it’s always best to ask people directly when you have questions w them.
They are expecting you to emote more — perhaps showing happiness or fondness — when you’re w them, and because you “don’t have alot of expression in [your] face” and don’t “let your feelings show” so openly they’re insecure and think you have little feelings for them or are guarding your feelings around them because maybe you don’t trust them.
Use this knowledge of how you might be (what people have told you about you) to your advantage (1) by helping people out by expressing yourself w more words of what you’re feeling or thinking to “lessen the impact” of your “puzzling nature” to them, and (2) because you seem to have a “poker face,” have you ever thought of taking up playing cards for money as a profession? 😀
