Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Do fish have feelings?

If you’ve eaten and enjoyed squid and/or octopus, does it bother you to know they are intelligent creatures?

Somehow it bothers me less to eat meat that comes from a dumb animal, like chicken or cow. But that doesn’t make sense. Who decides how dumb is dumb enough?

My dad took us fishing several times when we were little and I saw what happened when we caught one, the hook going through its face, its body wriggling like a tongue. The first time, maybe 4 years old, I cried.

“They don’t feel pain the same way we do. This doesn’t even hurt this little guy,” said Dad. He was absolutely firm in his answer, and at that age I always believed him.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
When I was first becoming vegetarian, I still ate fish, on the rationale that they are pretty dumb. But it didn't take me long to stop, because they are sentient beings.
My brother does a lot of fishing, and it is usually catch-and-release. On the one hand, letting the fish go seems kind. On the other hand, he has just stuck a hook through their face and dragged them out of their natural habitat. I truly feel ambivalent about this, to the point that I wonder sometimes about trying it myself, but then I don't.
atlantic59 · 61-69, M
@ThePatientAnarchist that really shows me perspective. Thanks