Boxing What-ifs: Sugar Ray Robinson vs. Sugar Ray Leonard

Battle of the Sugar Rays! Robinson vs. Leonard is another popular boxing dream match as both are considered the pound for pound greatest boxers of all time and the similarities between them go beyond sharing the same nickname as both were strikingly similar in skill. Even if they hadn't shared the same nickname, they'd probably still be compared, with many theorizing on who would win in a hypothetical bout. But before we get to analyzing these fighters, there are two things to address first: how both fought at various weight classes and how both have a greatly different number of total fights.

With this matchup comes something of an issue of establishing a right set-up in what weight class they would fight in as both Sugar Rays fought and exceled in multiple weight divisions over the course of their careers. Robinson having fought between 135 lbs. and 175 lbs. from 1940-1965 and Leonard having fought between 147 lbs. and 175 lbs. between 1977 and 1997. It's not so simple like the previous entry in this series Tyson vs. Ali, since, of course, both only ever fought at heavyweight. After doing my research, however, it seems widely agreed-upon that both Robinson and Leonard were at their best at welterweight (147 lbs, to be exact) so this hypothetical bout will see them both fighting as such.

I've seen a lot of arguments claiming Robinson would win because he had more fights (201 total) than Leonard did (40 total). But it's not fair to give Robinson any edge just because he had more fights because the two come from very different boxing eras. During Robinson's time, television was still in its infancy, so official bouts would mainly be held in club venues, allowing boxers to have hundreds of fights throughout their careers. Once matches started taking place solely on television where there was more money and exposure, it changed the boxing landscape forever. But because it takes more time to arrange a fight on live TV, boxers started having far less active careers from then on. Obviously, Robinson was around when this partnership between boxing and television had been going on for years, so again, it just wouldn't be fair to argue that Robinson would win because he had more fights.

Now that we have what weight division this fight would take place in and the record non-argument out of the way, it's time to analyze these two fighters for their strengths and weakness and what advantages or disadvantages they might have over one another. Five different points will be taken into account: fighting style, punching power, hand and foot speed, defense and durability, and endurance. Now, these two were indeed incredibly similar and seemed pretty evenly matched in many ways. But I really did my research here, so don't you dare accuse me of being lazy when I just say they were even in certain areas!


Perhaps the most daunting similarities between these two fighters is how versatile their fighting styles were! Both could adopt almost any style, be it brawling toe-to-toe or being slick counter-boxers. Both put offense over defense and both had a talent for exploiting their opponents' weaknesses. Neither have an edge over one another in terms of style. If these two had ever fought, I think the most interesting thing to see would be what techniques they would use against each other and how they would choose to adapt their styles during the fight.


This one's a bit tricky as both possessed great strength and achieved most of their victories by knockout. Out of Robinson's 174 wins, 109 were by KO, giving him a knockout-to-win ratio of 62.64%. Out of Leonard's 36 wins, 25 were by KO, giving him a 69.44% knockout-to-win ratio. Leonard was able to knock out a bigger fighter than Robinson ever did during his catchweight bout against the light heavyweight Donnie Lalonde. Robinson, however, scored knockouts against some of the best middleweight contenders of his time such Gene Fullmer, Bobo Olson and Randy Turpin. Sure Leonard was able to knockout some of his biggest competitors too, but these were always later in the fights after he was able to wear them down long enough. Robinson managed to finish his fights against his toughest foes much sooner, so for that, he gets the edge in knockout power, if only a slight edge.


For foot speed, both were pretty nimble geniuses when it came to their footwork; able to quickly maneuver themselves around their opponents with ease. Hand speed is a different story. While both were incredibly fast with throwing punches, Leonard was significantly quicker than Robinson. He's often hailed as one of the fastest punchers in boxing history, if not the fastest. He could throw lightning-quick combinations in a matter of seconds with very few other boxers in history able compare against him. Robinson was no slouch with his shots - he was one of the fastest of his generation, perhaps the fastest of them all! But Leonard was simply faster.


As mentioned earlier, both had more commendable offense than defense. Both relied on their foot speed to dodge and work their way around their foes, which served them well enough. Each of them had pretty stout chins that could take a great deal of punishment as well. Both had been dropped a few times, mainly in the later half of their careers when they were past their prime, but they each only have one knockout loss. Robinson only because he collapsed from heat exhaustion and Leonard because he was fighting at 40 years old. I couldn't anything that hints one surpasses the other, so I'm going to say they were equal on both fronts.


When either weren't able to finish their fights before the match was over, both could very easily go the distance and win via decision. Even when they'd show signs of fatigue, they had enough left in their tank to carry on fighting and ultimately win the match. When it comes to stamina, Robinson and Leonard are once again evenly matched.


Now that we have all factors considered, who would win in this match between two of these all-time greatest pound-for-pound boxers?

In this hypothetical fight, I believe it would be an exciting and competitive fight throughout. Both would take turns serving as aggressor while the other takes up a defensive stance to counter. Leonard would be the first to continuously advance on Robinson once it become clear he was the faster puncher. He would attempt to capitalize on this by shooting flurries at Robinson to try and take him down as quickly as he could. But being at a disadvantage in hand speed would be no issue for Robinson as he could easily adapt using his quick reflexes to counter him and his nimble feet to dodge. Any of Leonard's punches that landed could be easily shaken off and vice versa for any of Robinson's blows that caught Leonard. Both might get frustrated trying to exploit each other's weaknesses only to find they don't have any and it's like fighting their own mirror image!

Going into the later rounds, the fight would be extremely close but by this point, it would become clear who is fairing just slightly better. Robinson would understand fully that Leonard is one hell of an opponent! One he knows he can't put away with a knockout and that it would be too risky for him to try by duking it out with him considering his slower hand speed. But there is one thing he has over Leonard: skill. Despite how similar they both are, Robinson is able to stay one step ahead of him. In the end, it would boil down to who can out-counter the other and Robinson would prove to be the more cunning counter-boxer come the end of the 15th round. By a razor-thin margin, Robinson wins by unanimous decision, thus emerging as the superior Sugar Ray.

What this match would ultimately come down to is who had superior boxing skills. One could say Leonard had every right to use the Sugar Ray moniker because he really was comparable to Robinson. He was one of the best of his time and is one of the best pound-for-pound boxers ever! But Robinson was simply the better boxer. He's considered by many to not just be one of the greatest pound-for-pound boxers of all time, but the greatest. His boxing ability was unparalleled! I don't think anyone would doubt it would be a great match if Leonard fought Robinson, but as exceptional as Leonard was, Robinson is still in a league of his own. The winner is Sugar Ray Robinson!

---

But this is just my opinion on who I think would win. Whether you agree or disagree, feel free to make your case in the comments below.

Either way, thanks for reading!