I had a "makeover" once. I had to pay money to go down to the shop and come out looking like a streetwalker. It was so bad that people stared at me the whole time I was walking back to work...and not in a good way. My co-worker was horrified. Finally I rubbed it all off, and put it back on MY way, and my co-worker said it looked MUCH better.

Some would be offended and think you are telling them they need one... I don't wear makeup at all... not my thing but I wouldn't be offended just confused because it wouldn't fit who I am. It's hard to answer this question for every woman. We are all different.

No, I would just be annoyed that I had to pretend to like it.

I guess it would depend on the intent and if it's with their consent or not.

I'd like it, I'd see it as they just wanted to do something nice for me

It would be polite to ask if the person wants it ...or not.

Uhhh, I guess not? Not if they know you love it

They obviously don't know me very well.

Hmmmmmm could d makeover b a paper bag

Most people don't like it.