Asking
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

God, the Holocaust and Etty Hillesum

One rather shocking question is why did God let the Holocaust happen. Let me now try to answer the question. Your views may not be mine but atleast we'll have thought about it :)

Firstly, while the Holocaust was by no means Christian, the shocking truth is it could never have happened without the centuries of Church persecution of the Jews which came before it and a theology that demonised them.

Secondly, the Holocaust is a prime example of the evil humanity is capable of perpetrating. We may not know the reasons why God allowed this, yet God shared the suffering of His chosen people. He was, like believing Jews know only too well, not distant.

Finally, we are inclined by nature toward selfishness and sin so in this view He is God the omnipotent, the all-powerful Creator, but He is not omnibenevolent because He did not create our souls in a way that predispositioned us all for salvation.

Nicholas Wolterstorff, writing against the grain of centuries of Christian theology, states the seemingly obvious: “Given that all human actions are temporal,” he reasons, “those actions of God which are ‘response’ are temporal as well.”

Personally, I've read quite a few books on the subject matter but yet again I like particulary what Rowan Williams said in ending the following talk with Reza Shah-Kazemi about Etty Hillesum.

[media=https://youtu.be/jrUoNsbphCs]
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
InHeaven · F
...well, when Jews crucified God didn’t they curse themselves by saying .... “His blood be upon us and upon our children.” 🤔🤔🤔 They kinda asked for it themselves in a way maybe
val70 · 51-55
@InHeaven I'm sorry, but it were the Romans who crucified Christ. The Annals by Tacitus from AD 115 mentioned the Roman prefect Pontius Pilate executing Jesus, alluding to crucifixion, and placed that event within the timeframe that agrees with Christian gospels. The Romans always crucified their own prisoners, certaintly in a province that was Roman. St Paul was taken in person by a centurian to Rome to be judged and punished just because he was Roman. They did take the execution of the law very seriously then. Christ was judged by Roman law for sedition against the local establishment albeit Piltate didn't agree to the punishment
InHeaven · F
@val70 romans only nailed the nails into the cross as it was “their job”, but jews convicted him and yelled His blood on their children. Pilate wanted to let Him go alive but jew priests insisted He be crucified and DEAD. Don’t blame “evil” God allowing “evil” things to completely innocent jews. Nope. They brought it on themselves. But now its all “romans’ fault” and “bad God” . As always
val70 · 51-55
@InHeaven I guess that you don't know the expression "washing ones hands off it" in Roman law either then. Strange logic that :-)