Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why does Zelenskyy invoke tragic events?

Since Russia invaded Ukraine in February, Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has invoked the Holocaust to Israel, the Blitz to the British Parliament, Pearl Harbour to the U.S Congress, and the Berlin Wall to the German Bundestag. The most inappropriate comparison has definitely been the Holocaust, because this was not a war or an attack on a nation for political reasons. Jewish people were systematically targeted by the Nazis and there was absolutely no provocation for it, and nothing they could do about it. As I have said to people in my post about Ukraine, in a war you are presented with choices...you can choose to fight, or you can choose to surrender. If you surrender, the general rule is that your army and your people will no longer be under attack. Even if they have to live under an oppressive government, they are still *not* going to be subjected to mass murder in the way that Jewish people were during the Holocaust.

It seems to me that Zelenskyy will just use whatever tragic event he can with the intention of targeting his specific audience with it. This is obviously because he wants to get something out of them (e.g military equipment, financial aid, etc.) but it's so incredibly disingenuous. I think his thoughts on the Holocaust in particular are testament to how so many former Soviet (yes, I know it doesn't exist now but the mentality still does) Jews still view the Holocaust. I know that many in Ukraine and in other former Soviet States do recognize the horror for what it was...there are some who just don't though. I see Zelenskyy as more of a Ukrainian nationalist than as someone whose great-grandparents perished because they were Jews. His grandfather and other family members were allowed by the Soviets to join the Soviet Army.

In Ukraine, because of a combination of Soviet policies and Ukrainian nationalism, there historically hasn't been that much openness about the Holocaust and how Jewish people were slaughtered en masse simply for being Jews. They were told that all people in Eastern Europe suffered, and that the Nazis killed everyone. They were made to believe, or at least say they believed, that there was nothing unique to Jewish suffering. I think if Zelenskyy had a greater awareness and didn't prioritize nationalism over basic historical realities, he could never have used the Holocaust as a comparison to what is presently happening in Ukraine. It's genuinely beyond comprehension that he did.

Back to the wider point I am making though, it isn't right or fair to go to other nations and bring up unfortunate events they have had in recent history just to get your own way.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
SW-User
He has a responsibility to keep the war in people's minds and at the forefront of the news agenda. If he uses dramatic language, imagery etc, in order to do that, then i think he is absolutely right to do so.
SW-User
@SW-User So you think it is right to compare the war in Ukraine to the Holocaust?
SW-User
@SW-User Please read carefully my words...its not a question of right and wrong in basic terms. He is doing what he feels is neccessary and i support him fully as he does all he can to defend his country against the Russian butcher, who i hope will be remembered as a war criminal, child killer and despot of the worst sort.
SW-User
@SW-User No, I suggest you read carefully my words: do you think it is right to compare the war in Ukraine to the Holocaust?

Yes or no? Answer the question.
SW-User
@SW-User I have answered your ridiculous question…please read and REFLECT on what i said. Your argument is fatuous,,,sometimes it is best to move on when your intellect is not sufficient to the task.
SW-User
@SW-User Except you didn't answer it, because I wanted an answer in simple terms. I will assume that you do think this war is as bad as the Holocaust in every respect then.

And now, you're getting blocked.