Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why the Gaza War narrative has taken over the left

These days, you can't mention a tragic event like the Oklahoma City bombing or the JetSet Club collapse without a chorus of people screaming "Gaza has it worse." It's become one of the main focuses of the left. Other far worse situations are either ignored or explained away.

This obsession fits the Christian redemption story that the western left abandoned and needs to replace with a secular version. We're taught that by living in the west, we've inherited the "original sins" of racism, colonialism, white supremacy, capitalism, environmental destruction, and other "sins" we can't escape. So the secular "salvation" is through the suffering of the innocent, Christ-like Palestinians, who take the place of Jesus by literally "dying for our sins" at the hands of the Jews, who are also guilty of killing the original Jesus. By elevating "free Palestine" to a sacred cause and opposing "Zionism," the liberal westerner is absolved of sin, the same way his Christian forbears were absolved by accepting Jesus and rejecting Satan.
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
I find it fascinating that the actual deaths of human beings isn't important, it's the fact people don't talk about it in a way that you approve of that's the priority.
@CountScrofula Well, the deaths of actual human beings isn't important if it's happening in Syria, Eritrea, Sudan, or Yemen.
BlueVeins · 22-25
@LeopoldBloom Yeah there famously was never any news coverage, outrage, or widespread international condemnation of the Syrian Civil War.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
@LeopoldBloom I'm not talking about Yemen I'm talking about Palestine.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
@LeopoldBloom And to just put the question to you - what is to be done about Gaza and West Bank?

Our tax dollars are paying for this. So in the spirit of democracy you're in charge. What do you do about them? Let's assume Hamas will never release the hostages or disband.
@CountScrofula You said it best.
@CountScrofula https://similarworlds.com/life/5354114-Its-okay-to-mourn-a-death-but-remember-this
@CountScrofula If you were in charge of the Palestinians, what would you have them do? Surrender or keep fighting?
Oof.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
@LeopoldBloom I don't understand. The IDF are an army who follow orders from a government. The Palestinians have no army or government. They don't even have buildings.
@CountScrofula Hamas is an organized militia. So let's say you're in charge of Hamas. Assuming your main concern is the welfare of the people of Gaza (something Hamas is definitely not concerned with), what would you do?

Also, in the West Bank, the PA is definitely a government headed by Mahmoud Abbas.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
@LeopoldBloom Oh I'd disband Hamas immediately.
@CountScrofula Guy's never heard of de facto rule.
CountScrofula · 41-45, M
@LeopoldBloom I'm confused. Genuinely.

Are you trying to say that the Palestinians all follow orders from a central command that could give an order for them to cease fighting, and that would end the conflict?
BlueVeins · 22-25
@LeopoldBloom If you're asking what someone would do if they were in charge of [ethnicity], I think that's a good sign that things went wrong somewhere in your thought process.