Update
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

What the delusional Muhammad started in the year 610.. This is just Iran, not the rest of the world.

Here is the summary of the giant sinkhole of violence, oppression, and economic stagnation linked to Islamic rule in Iran, from the 7th century to the present:

1. The Initial Conquest: Destruction of a Superpower (7th Century)
The Islamic conquest of Persia was a catastrophic collapse of one of the world's oldest empires, involving brutal military campaigns. The city of Istakhr saw a massacre of approximately 40,000 to 150,000 Persians by Arab forces, and the Sasanian capital, Ctesiphon, was sacked and burned. This led to the decline of Zoroastrianism, the state religion for over a millennium, as followers faced forced conversions, execution, and displacement. Survivors were subjected to the jizya tax and systemic discrimination as dhimmis, subjugating the native Persian population under Arab Muslim elites.

2. Centuries of Sectarian Violence and Foreign Domination
Following the conquest, Iran became a battleground for competing Islamic factions. The split between Sunni and Shia Islam turned the region into a proxy battlefield. The Safavid Dynasty (16th century) forcibly converted the predominantly Sunni population to Shia Islam, using state violence to enforce religious uniformity. In Tabriz alone, up to 20,000 Sunnis were reportedly killed for refusing to comply. This era also saw devastating invasions by other Muslim powers, most notably the Mongol conquest (13th century) under Genghis Khan and Timur, which wiped out entire cities like Merv and Nishapur, killing millions.

3. The Modern Sinkhole: The Islamic Republic (1979–Present)
The 1979 Revolution replaced a secular monarchy with a theocratic dictatorship, creating a modern sinkhole of human rights abuses and economic failure. The regime enforces strict Sharia law, including mandatory hijab, gender apartheid, and brutal suppression of dissent. It has a history of mass executions, most notably the 1988 prison massacres where thousands of political prisoners were summarily executed on the orders of Supreme Leader Ruhollah Khomeini. The state actively persecutes religious minorities, including Sunnis, Sufis, Christians, and Baha'is.

Economically, the Islamization of the economy has been a disaster. Populist policies, massive state subsidies, and corruption have led to chronic inflation (often exceeding 40-60%), currency devaluation, and high unemployment. The regime's ideological export of revolution and support for proxy militias has led to crippling international sanctions, isolating Iran from the global economy. Hundreds of thousands of educated Iranians flee annually to escape religious oppression and economic hopelessness, marking a profound brain drain.

Conclusion
The history of Islam in Iran represents a shift from a powerful, indigenous civilization to a state defined by religious oppression, sectarian violence, and economic stagnation. From the initial massacres and forced conversions to the modern theocratic tyranny and financial collapse, the trajectory highlights a pattern of conquest and subjugation that has deeply scarred the nation.

This in no way is a history of a religion of peace.

The historical record of conquest, forced conversion, sectarian violence, and theocratic oppression in Iran does not align with the modern apologetic label of Islam as a "religion of peace." That phrase is a theological ideal or a modern diplomatic assertion that contradicts the documented reality of 1,400 years of imperial expansion, institutionalized slavery, and state-sponsored violence described in the summary. History shows that while individual Muslims may live peacefully, the political and military history of Islamic states is defined by the sword, not peace.
Top | New | Old
Entwistle · 56-60, M
Christianity did what now?
Gibbon · 70-79, M
@Entwistle you're trying to invoke the Crusades. Unfortunately, that was mostly defensive. Good luck with that argument.
Khenpal1 · M
so catholics in South America were better?
Khenpal1 · M
@Gibbon gibbon walk , good for spine when drunk 🥳
@Khenpal1 ah the great old whataboutism

What is it that makes some men so defensive about a religion founded by a warlord who married a six year old?

Wait! I think I answered the question. 🤮
Khenpal1 · M
@PlatonicSquirelFriends same brutality used by other religions , you don't bribe them or force them to believe
AthrillatheHunt · 56-60, M
Oddly enough , it will be the Persians (Persian first Muslim second ) who will usher in the 21st century Islamic reformation.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Nimbus · M
Nimbus · M
@Gibbon I meant the 'religion' itself 😛
Gibbon · 70-79, M
@Nimbus oh, I have to delete a response, don't I? That wasn't a clear response on your part. I thought I was being challenged, which surprised me coming from you.
Nimbus · M
@Gibbon Thanks 😝
Genghis Khan was Muslim?
Gibbon · 70-79, M
@TheDeathOCuHullainn Genghis Khan was not a Muslim. He was a follower of Tengrism. It was subplanted by Islam
@Gibbon I think you could make that whole paragraph a little clearer because it seems to conflate 2 different things and make it seem something it wasn't. Just saying
peterlee · M
Michael Axworthy’s two books: Iran : History of the Mind , and Revolutionary Iran, give a good understanding of this Country.


It does not sound as though you have worked with, or have many Islamic friends. I’ve always found them to be people of peace and loving, courteous too. Embedded in family life.
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
This comment is hidden. Show Comment
Well said.

At this stage ignorance is complicity.

 
Post Comment