This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
HumanEarth · F
Al Jolson was one of those singers from the 1920s that people often say is overrated. He had a powerful voice and was one of the first big stars in sound films, getting super popular, especially for his performances in blackface.
But here’s why some folks think he’s overrated:
Controversial Style
Jolson's use of blackface has gotten a lot of slack over the years, kinda overshadowing his musical talent. Sure, he was groundbreaking in some ways, but today, his style seems pretty outdated and problematic.
Limited Range of Material
A lot of Jolson’s songs kinda sound the same, following similar emotional vibes and musical styles. Critics say this makes him seem less artistically deep next to other artists who tried out different genres.
Cultural Impact vs. Musical Legacy
Even though Jolson was a big deal and super influential back in the day, some people think his legacy is more about his persona and not so much about how great his music actually was. That’s where some say he’s overrated when you look back at history.
But here’s why some folks think he’s overrated:
Controversial Style
Jolson's use of blackface has gotten a lot of slack over the years, kinda overshadowing his musical talent. Sure, he was groundbreaking in some ways, but today, his style seems pretty outdated and problematic.
Limited Range of Material
A lot of Jolson’s songs kinda sound the same, following similar emotional vibes and musical styles. Critics say this makes him seem less artistically deep next to other artists who tried out different genres.
Cultural Impact vs. Musical Legacy
Even though Jolson was a big deal and super influential back in the day, some people think his legacy is more about his persona and not so much about how great his music actually was. That’s where some say he’s overrated when you look back at history.