Random
Only logged in members can reply and interact with the post.
Join SimilarWorlds for FREE »

Why did God create animals with the capacity to suffer?

[b]What purpose does the suffering of animals serve?[/b]
This page is a permanent link to the reply below and its nested replies. See all post replies »
fakable · T
propagation
@fakable
I don't understand. What does the capacity of animals to suffer have to do with propogation?
fakable · T
@Pikachu
hedgehog sleeps
lion eats the hedgehog
hedgehog doesn't suffer
hedgehog sleeps
lion ate the hedgehog
there is no hedgehog
that was the last hedgehog
here are no more hedgehogs

by the way, the lion is gone too
the lion doesn't suffer
he choked on a hedgehog

so they're all extinct

but the african diplodocus suffers, so it wouldn't eat the hedgehogs, because they're prickly

african diplodocus survived
they multiplied and now they rule the world
@fakable
I think that was perhaps an effort to describe adaptive advantage?
But the ability to suffer need not be part of reproductive and survival success. Mortality could theoretically occur and propagate fitter populations without those populations having the capacity to suffer.
fakable · T
@Pikachu
theoretically it could be anything
but it is what it is
@fakable

It is what it is. My question is why. What is the justification?
fakable · T
@Pikachu
the point of what you call suffering is to create reflective responses to environmental stimuli

It is part of the adaptive mechanism of survival

---

p.s.

I'm cold
the fire is warm
i move closer to the fire
the fire burns
it hurts me
i 'll move back a little

that's the point
@fakable

Oh i understand stimulus response but that's not the same as suffering.
A bacteria has stimulus response.
But what does suffering add to that? Feeling pain and not only reacting to it as a stimulus to be avoided but also finding that stimulus traumatic, upsetting, terrifying?
These are not necessary. A simple algorithm of if x stimulus then y response would suffice to meet the same end.
So why Biblically speaking, do animals have the capacity to suffer?
fakable · T
@Pikachu

god's will is above your comprehension
humble yourselves before the divine plan

100% biblical answer to all questions
@fakable

lol yes, the "god works in mysterious ways" clause is often invoked.